Moderator: Andrew
RonaldDupris wrote:Going to start a shitstorm for saying this but:
Toto isn't Toto without David Paich. So if Paich isn't ever coming back, I'd rather Toto just call it quits.
That's not a knock on original members Luke and Steve P but Toto is and always will be Paich and Jeff Porcaro's creation. Without at least one of them in the band, Toto should not exist.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:RonaldDupris wrote:Going to start a shitstorm for saying this but:
Toto isn't Toto without David Paich. So if Paich isn't ever coming back, I'd rather Toto just call it quits.
That's not a knock on original members Luke and Steve P but Toto is and always will be Paich and Jeff Porcaro's creation. Without at least one of them in the band, Toto should not exist.
Ridiculous. The FIB show I saw with Greg on keys was amazing. While I wish Paich was currently there, this isn't the first time he had to step out. TOTO currently has more original and longtime members than most bands - Lenny, Joe, Warren, Steve P, and Luke.
RonaldDupris wrote:That period with Greg was awful and a trainwreck. 2003-2008 was the darkest time in Toto's history.
RonaldDupris wrote:That period with Greg was awful and a trainwreck. 2003-2008 was the darkest time in Toto's history.
RonaldDupris wrote:That period with Greg was awful and a trainwreck. 2003-2008 was the darkest time in Toto's history.
Andrew wrote:RonaldDupris wrote:That period with Greg was awful and a trainwreck. 2003-2008 was the darkest time in Toto's history.
What utter rot! Greg was awesome...and that album/tour was quite spectacular.
Andrew wrote:Greg not professional? Now I know you’re having a laugh.
And FiB was and remains a masterpiece.
RonaldDupris wrote:
I think their last record Toto XIV from 2015 is their all-time masterpiece.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:RonaldDupris wrote:
I think their last record Toto XIV from 2015 is their all-time masterpiece.
To me, both FIB and XIV have some great moments. But masterpieces? Nah. I think even "Old is New" is more cohesive overall.
Ehwmatt wrote:I tend to agree that FIB is not cohesive. Some great moments as you said, but it sounds more like a side project for a Toto member or two. You can hear elements of the signature sound here and there, but it just didn't seem like Toto at the end of the day. XIV, on the other hand, is a masterpiece to me. Killer album.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:RonaldDupris wrote:That period with Greg was awful and a trainwreck. 2003-2008 was the darkest time in Toto's history.
FIB show I saw was great - even Bobby blew me away.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:I tend to agree that FIB is not cohesive. Some great moments as you said, but it sounds more like a side project for a Toto member or two. You can hear elements of the signature sound here and there, but it just didn't seem like Toto at the end of the day. XIV, on the other hand, is a masterpiece to me. Killer album.
XIV is pretty good. Some songs - like Burn or Fortune - miss the mark for me.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests