So Who Had The Better Solo Material DDY, TS Or JY???

[masque]

for me I enjoy tommy's solo work the best. i really enjoyed the girls with guns album and still listen to it on a semi regular basis. 7 deadly zens is probably my favorite of his. there are a few songs on what if that i despise but there are three or four that i love so it's a mixed bag for me.....i have grown to like ambition much better in the last few years.

damn yankees is not a solo tommy effort but i freaking love damn yankees and anything he does with jack blades.....shaw/blades is incredible.

dennis's solo stuff has always been a mixed bag for me....several great songs mixed in with stuff i would have been embarassed myself to write.

even though i am a huge JY fan the only thing he did i really like is raised by wolves thing which was helped tremenosly by his band. out on a day pass may be one of the worst things I have ever heard any member of styx ever do.....sorry JY.

overall, i think you could take the best of all of the solo albums and have a couple of real good styx albums. but that's usually the case with most bands that had mulitple writers sharing songs on a cd and then all of a sudden their writing is carrying their whole solo cd.

[Higgy]

What were Chuck and John doing during the solo period? Were either of them on any of the solo albums?

[brywool]

TS - hands down.

Dennis was just trying too hard to be Barry Manilow. He had some great individual tracks, but as a whole, gotta go with Shaw.
Young's were terrible.... The JY Group was pretty cool though.

[Jodes]

What were Chuck and John doing during the solo period? Were either of them on any of the solo albums?

I think John played on Out In A Day Pass.. To my knowledge Chuck was never on any of the solo cds.

JY appeared on Tommy's Ambition CD as well.

[Abitaman]

What were Chuck and John doing during the solo period? Were either of them on any of the solo albums?

I think John played on Out In A Day Pass.. To my knowledge Chuck was never on any of the solo cds.

JY appeared on Tommy's Ambition CD as well.

John played on the remake of Young Man on that cd.