Moderator: Andrew
[/quote]I can play that game too. Why does DeYoung mention how long he's been married at every concert? (gratuitous applause?) Why does he have his sister in law, and amateur wife and daughter on stage at every show? Why do we need to hear the same 'schoolmarm' motivational speeches everytime DeYoung performs?
Adam wrote:ItsMyLife: Question: Why must this line-up cover an old Styx song with every release?
Adam: Oh, I get it. Watch Styx make a move, mull over it, look for something to complain about, and then post it as if you're proving some point.
I can play that game too. Why does DeYoung mention how long he's been married at every concert? (gratuitous applause?) Why does he have his sister in law, and amateur wife and daughter on stage at every show? Why do we need to hear the same 'schoolmarm' motivational speeches everytime DeYoung performs?
Adam wrote:It’s the endless taunting attitude dished out by a number of DDY-ettes that make me jump into the pissing contest. I say if Dennis can bring up family amateurs and give redundant, stale speeches at every performance, then Styx has a perfect right to rearrange, redo and rerecord any of their old material, without the DeYoungians pointing out how it’s an indicator of how much they need Dennis. Styx seems to be maintaining an absolutely successful touring business (without the nightly sermons of Father DeYoung).
SweatyAdamBlue wrote:Okay, so from where ItsMyLife sits (stands?) DDY's live "Music Of Styx" CDs/shows/whatever falls into the 'lame' category...that unless unless ItsMyLife deems these covers to NOT be for the "wrong" or commercial reasons.
SweatyAdamBlue wrote:Again, for the Court, I site Clapton's bluesy "Layla" from his unplugged disc.
Question: Why must this line-up cover an old Styx song with every release?
Adam wrote:Adam: And since you mentioned it, the only “cover” I can think of on Cyclorama is a re-arranged snippet of “Fooling Yourself” (BUT I THOUGHT SONGS YOU FREAKIN’ WROTE ARE NOT COVERS!)
Adam wrote:which not only features a guest appearance by one of rock n roll’s all time GREATS (I know, ItsMyLife has no regard for rock history, so the Beach Boys of course wouldn’t matter) but lasts a minute AND ISN’T CREDITED WITH THE TITLE “FOOLING YOURSELF”!
Adam wrote:ItsMyLife: An unplugged album is a live album. The main purpose of those is to reinvent/reinterpret your own songs.
Adam: Says you. I say the artist can do whatever the heck they WANT, which includes adding a sappy ballad like “Babe” to a rock band album, or the crescendo of a symphony orchestra at the end a Beatle album. I say an artist/act are free to rearrange their material anyway they like WHENEVER they like. Who are you – the MUSIC POLICE?
Adam wrote:And if you really wanna get into picking, Clapton’s UnPlugged album was almost about as “live” as “Big Bang Theory”, since it was created in the controlled environment of a TV studio (where only a few seats were given to selected vip’s – no “real” audience) and filmed, recorded & edited a number of times, a number of takes, ultimately re-edited & remixed.
Adam wrote:(Oh, and feel free to call me SweatyAdamBlue if it gets you off, but I think your Bon Jovi moniker is kind of EMBARASSING, you know? That song makes me nauseous and the guy’s singing is strained, annoying and painful. )
AdamHeartMother wrote:Quick show of hands out there - HOW MANY READING THESE WORDS ACTUALLY THINK JON BON JOVI IS A GOOD SINGER?
ItsMyLife wrote:classicstyxfan wrote:I saw Andrew drop an "F" bomb of his own over on the Journey board.....
Of course, they DESERVED it ! All in all, we're pretty well behaved, at least when you compare us to THAT group !
I'd think we could all handle the occassional F bomb. Sheesh.
I use it for effect.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests