Page 1 of 2

Styx/Def Leppard Montreal 7/17/07

PostPosted: Wed Jul 18, 2007 11:32 pm
by MtlLady
Boy, was it ever HOT at the Bell Center last night!

My ears are still ringing. :-) (My son found it funny that mom wasn't playing her CD in the car this morning because my ears hurt. Some people's kids!!) :-)

I had a floor seat, in front of mid-stage, could see (AND HEAR) everything, bought the t-shirt (two, actually, I'm such a groupie).

The Bell Center was packed. When Styx came on, about half of the audience went nuts. The other half were young teenagers who where there for Def Leppard and had probably never heard of Styx. One of the teenagers behind me was looking at her mother and I (who were enjoying the Styx show) as if we had grown horns. Styx got a standing O and an encore. They played 90 mins, including the encore.

Anyway, the Styx boys let it fly!! And yes, they played SMB, as many of you predicted. A few lighters went up during the song. They kept telling us how much they loved Montreal. Sounds familiar .... :-)

Two suprises of the night - They played MIDNIGHT RIDE!!!! I was one happy camper to hear this one live, finally. Say what you want about JY, but he can still let this one rip!! And - CHUCK CAME TO MONTREAL!!! He played, sang, smiled, walked the stage with his AC/DC t-shirt. It must have cost him, though, as when it came time to leave the stage, he needed the help of a roadie and the handrail to get down the stairs off the stage. What a trouper.

Montreal Setlist was:

Blue Collar Man (Tommy)
Grand Illusion (Gowan)
Too Much Time On My Hands (Tommy)
Suite Madam Blue (Gowan)
MIDNIGHT RIDE (JY)
Criminal Mind (Gowan - nice harmony arrangement by the guys here)
CHUCK CAME OUT
Fooling Yourself(The Angry Young Man) (Tommy)
Miss America (JY)
Come Sail Away (Gowan)
Encore: Renegade (Tommy)

Compared to the American setlist, which was listed as the following on another thread:

Blue Collar Man
Grand Illusion
Too Much Time On My Hands
Lorelei
I Am The Walrus
Crystal Ball
Fooling Yourself(The Angry Young Man)
Miss America
Come Sail Away
Renegade

Now. As for Gowan. SMB wasn't as bad as I thought it would be, probably because I was warned. Some of his onstage antics are funny (like how he travels the stage with that polaroid camera - during Miss America he takes a pic of JY doing the "ward off evil spirits" sign with his fingers and flings the shot in the audience). But his climbing on his keyboards and jumping off his dias is a bit much. But, he does what he does.

Todd Sucherman sure works hard for his pay! No slouch there. It's exhausting just to watch.

Tommy's voice was right on - and he's still as cute as ever. Guitars were tight, JY and Tommy never missed a note. Ricky's voice certainly adds to the harmonies.

Great show!

P.S. I checked the pictures of Def Leppard on the 14th that were linked on this thread and the guys are wearing (or not wearing) the exact same clothes as they wore last night. Same stage, same songs. But hey, it works!

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 12:31 am
by bugsymalone
Love ya, Amanda, but all I can say to SMB done by ANYONE other than Dennis is --- UGH!!! :wink:

Bugsy

A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 12:36 am
by kipthekid
What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 12:52 am
by MtlLady
bugsymalone wrote:Love ya, Amanda, but all I can say to SMB done by ANYONE other than Dennis is --- UGH!!! :wink:

Bugsy


LOL! It certainly wasn't Dennis, but my ears didn't fold up and close inside themselves either. :-) The music saved the song's last shred of dignity.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 2:18 am
by blt man
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


Lady probably does not rock hard enough in the opinion of the current Styx members to play in a shortened set in front of a Def Leppard crowd.

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 2:34 am
by SuiteMadameBlue
bugsymalone wrote:Love ya, Amanda, but all I can say to SMB done by ANYONE other than Dennis is --- UGH!!! :wink:

Bugsy


I feel the same way, in my opinion!! :lol:

I wish you could be up here on Friday to hear SMB live like it's suppose to be heard.................. :D

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 4:11 am
by rajah2165
blt man wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


Lady probably does not rock hard enough in the opinion of the current Styx members to play in a shortened set in front of a Def Leppard crowd.


Yes, Lady is one of those awful ballads that they must never play again...

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 4:48 am
by stabbim
rajah2165 wrote:Yes, Lady is one of those awful ballads that they must never play again...


If only.

Tailoring the set for a Canadian audience with SMB and ACM is probably the main point of dropping Lady.

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 5:31 am
by brywool
Note to Andrew-

Andrew- Please change every Styx thread's name to "DENNIS VS GOWAN".

It seems no matter what the topic, it all turns into that. boring...

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 9:57 am
by blt man
brywool wrote:Note to Andrew-

Andrew- Please change every Styx thread's name to "DENNIS VS GOWAN".

It seems no matter what the topic, it all turns into that. boring...


Well, other than Dennis' new CD and a couple of books there is not all that much to talk about. :D
And since fans are short for fanatics...

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 10:47 am
by piecesofeight
blt man wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


Lady probably does not rock hard enough in the opinion of the current Styx members to play in a shortened set in front of a Def Leppard crowd.



...and why even sing a song that written by someone-who was kicked out-that wrote it for his wife.
For many reason, no one should be singing Lady but Dennis.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Fri Jul 20, 2007 3:57 am
by SuiteMadameBlue
piecesofeight wrote:
blt man wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


Lady probably does not rock hard enough in the opinion of the current Styx members to play in a shortened set in front of a Def Leppard crowd.



...and why even sing a song that written by someone-who was kicked out-that wrote it for his wife.
For many reason, no one should be singing Lady but Dennis.


Thank you!! That's exactly how I feel too, same with the song "Babe". IMO

PostPosted: Fri Jul 20, 2007 4:01 am
by SuiteMadameBlue
brywool wrote:Note to Andrew-

Andrew- Please change every Styx thread's name to "DENNIS VS GOWAN".

It seems no matter what the topic, it all turns into that. boring...


LOL, that's funny!! You really think that these posts are THAT boring? I get a chuckle with some of the posts :)

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Fri Jul 20, 2007 3:28 pm
by Grotelul
piecesofeight wrote:
blt man wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


Lady probably does not rock hard enough in the opinion of the current Styx members to play in a shortened set in front of a Def Leppard crowd.



...and why even sing a song that written by someone-who was kicked out-that wrote it for his wife.
For many reason, no one should be singing Lady but Dennis.



If it's such personal song, maybe Dennis should only sing it to his wife in private...hmmmmm.... I could live with that.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 11:02 pm
by Uno_up
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


"Lady" was played at this show. (I was there)

MtlLady inadvertently left it off her setlist.

PostPosted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 11:50 pm
by Zan
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:
brywool wrote:Note to Andrew-

Andrew- Please change every Styx thread's name to "DENNIS VS GOWAN".

It seems no matter what the topic, it all turns into that. boring...


LOL, that's funny!! You really think that these posts are THAT boring? I get a chuckle with some of the posts :)



I suggested "I know you are, but what am I?"

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 12:40 am
by MtlLady
One_Up wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


"Lady" was played at this show. (I was there)

MtlLady inadvertently left it off her setlist.


I'm sorry, but I'm pretty sure Styx didn't play Lady. I wrote all the songs down as they were being played and I would have remembered. Frankly I would have been stunned. Maybe I was too stunned to write it down!! LOL! I will ask my concert buddies just in case I had a brain fart, I have made errors before.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 12:56 am
by gr8dane
MtlLady wrote:
One_Up wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


"Lady" was played at this show. (I was there)

MtlLady inadvertently left it off her setlist.


I'm sorry, but I'm pretty sure Styx didn't play Lady. I wrote all the songs down as they were being played and I would have remembered. Frankly I would have been stunned. Maybe I was too stunned to write it down!! LOL! I will ask my concert buddies just in case I had a brain fart, I have made errors before.


Last time I saw Styx play SMB,Gowan would sing O-CA-NA -DA,while the others sang A-ME-RI-CA.Did he do this in Montreal?

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 1:26 am
by MtlLady
gr8dane wrote:Last time I saw Styx play SMB,Gowan would sing O-CA-NA -DA,while the others sang A-ME-RI-CA.Did he do this in Montreal?


LOL! That's funny! But no, he didn't try this one in Montreal. :-) I think I know why, but that's a topic for another board.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 1:40 am
by gr8dane
MtlLady wrote:
gr8dane wrote:Last time I saw Styx play SMB,Gowan would sing O-CA-NA -DA,while the others sang A-ME-RI-CA.Did he do this in Montreal?


LOL! That's funny! But no, he didn't try this one in Montreal. :-) I think I know why, but that's a topic for another board.


HA,I get you drift.
Maybe he would sing O-O-QUE-BEC.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 1:46 am
by MtlLady
gr8dane wrote:
MtlLady wrote:
gr8dane wrote:Last time I saw Styx play SMB,Gowan would sing O-CA-NA -DA,while the others sang A-ME-RI-CA.Did he do this in Montreal?


LOL! That's funny! But no, he didn't try this one in Montreal. :-) I think I know why, but that's a topic for another board.


HA,I get you drift.
Maybe he would sing O-O-QUE-BEC.


Good Lord No! That would be a study on how to start a riot. LOL!

But we digress ....

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 6:21 am
by Jodes
Every time I've heard Gowan to SMB, (in Canada and the US) he's never put the "O Canada" part in it..

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 9:33 am
by gr8dane
Jodes wrote:Every time I've heard Gowan to SMB, (in Canada and the US) he's never put the "O Canada" part in it..


This was in Owen Sound.
At this concert,I also saw the largest pair of ladies underwear ever.I would say, the approximate size of a 2 man tent.
It was hung on JY's guitarneck during a solo where he had his eyes closed.When he opened up his eyes ,he almost fell on his ass.
That was so effin funny.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 10:25 am
by Uno_up
MtlLady wrote:
One_Up wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


"Lady" was played at this show. (I was there)

MtlLady inadvertently left it off her setlist.


I'm sorry, but I'm pretty sure Styx didn't play Lady. I wrote all the songs down as they were being played and I would have remembered. Frankly I would have been stunned. Maybe I was too stunned to write it down!! LOL! I will ask my concert buddies just in case I had a brain fart, I have made errors before.


It was played.
I was singing (screaming it) so I didn't have to hear Gowan ;)

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 10:42 am
by gr8dane
One_Up wrote:
MtlLady wrote:
One_Up wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


"Lady" was played at this show. (I was there)

MtlLady inadvertently left it off her setlist.


I'm sorry, but I'm pretty sure Styx didn't play Lady. I wrote all the songs down as they were being played and I would have remembered. Frankly I would have been stunned. Maybe I was too stunned to write it down!! LOL! I will ask my concert buddies just in case I had a brain fart, I have made errors before.


It was played.
I was singing (screaming it) so I didn't have to hear Gowan ;)


Hi and welcome One-Upper.
You did not enjoy the show then?

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Tue Sep 11, 2007 12:25 pm
by Uno_up
gr8dane wrote:
One_Up wrote:
MtlLady wrote:
One_Up wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?" A U2 concert without "In the Name of Love?" Peanut butter without jelly?


"Lady" was played at this show. (I was there)

MtlLady inadvertently left it off her setlist.


I'm sorry, but I'm pretty sure Styx didn't play Lady. I wrote all the songs down as they were being played and I would have remembered. Frankly I would have been stunned. Maybe I was too stunned to write it down!! LOL! I will ask my concert buddies just in case I had a brain fart, I have made errors before.


It was played.
I was singing (screaming it) so I didn't have to hear Gowan ;)


Hi and welcome One-Upper.
You did not enjoy the show then?


Of course I loved the show! I've been a HUGE Styx fan ever since receiving my first album of any kind from Santa Claus (Equinox) in the mid-seventies. Gowan is an admirable replacement for DeYoung. My winkyman is a crack on all those who like to bash Larry. I'm just glad the show goes on.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Tue Sep 11, 2007 1:08 pm
by froy
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?"


Thats funny there's never been a Who concert with Teenage wasteland..
Never ever.

Re: A Styx concert without "Lady?"

PostPosted: Tue Sep 11, 2007 1:19 pm
by Zan
froy wrote:
kipthekid wrote:What's next, a Who concert without "Teenage Wasteland?"


Thats funny there's never been a Who concert with Teenage wasteland..
Never ever.




Froy is right. The name of the song is "Baba O'Riley."

PostPosted: Tue Sep 11, 2007 7:34 pm
by Andrew
brywool wrote:Note to Andrew-

Andrew- Please change every Styx thread's name to "DENNIS VS GOWAN".

It seems no matter what the topic, it all turns into that. boring...


It is getting a little sad. How about we all just argue overmy interview with Dennis?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 11, 2007 11:05 pm
by MtlLady
Andrew wrote:It is getting a little sad. How about we all just argue overmy interview with Dennis?


Sure, I can help you with that. :-)

I was hoping to get some info on his "plan" for this fall (hopefully for us Canadians!!). But it guess the info isn't ready to be released ... Rats. :-(

Okay, not an argument, exactly, more like a whine from Canada .... :(