froy wrote:brywool wrote:never got ND. He has the vocal range of about 5 notes. As far as concerts, yeah, I've heard his concerts are great. I just could never get into him. He's one of those guys that writes great tunes, but I just don't like his performance of them. It's weird how things are perceived so differently from different peeps.
Your right , You like the horrific Gowan but not Neil, Makes no sense.
Neil has one of the best concerts next to Paul..
Well, I'm not sure how Diamond (or guys like Springsteen) can be cited as good singers. Neither is.
Gowan, for what he does is decent. He's not Dennis, never said he was. I didn't say I love Gowan either, but I don't hate him "just because". The guy is talented as a pianist and as a vocalist. There are a bazillion different voices in the world. Dennis is one. Neil is one. Gowan is one. I just don't get the NeilAppeal. Seems like something for old OLD ladies.
Also, you judge Gowan singing Dennis' songs. Not really fair. Some of his own stuff is really good (some of it blows, just like Dennis', or Tommy, or even Paul's).