MR

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 2:41 am**

Well here it is the setlist

1. Fooling Yourself
2. "Superstars
3. "Miss America
4. "Man in the Wilderness
5. "The Grand Finale
6. "Great White Hope
7. Sing For The Day
8. Blue Collar Man
9. Renegade
10. "Aku-Aku"

Should be fun it would be better if it were original

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:00 am**

I thought they were playing both albums in their entirety?

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:02 am**

Bearded Clam wrote:I thought they were playing both albums in their entirety?

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs. Think about it.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:23 am**

"StyxCollector"

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs.

Yea what about the Dennis songs?

The Grand Illusion" DeYoung
Come Sail Away" DeYoung
Castle Walls" DeYoung
I'm O.K." DeYoung
The Message" (DeYoung
Lords of the Ring" DeYoung
Queen of Spades" DeYoung
Pieces of Eight" DeYoung

That's 8 Songs they are stealing

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:39 am**

froy wrote:
"StyxCollector"

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs.

Yea what about the Dennis songs?

The Grand Illusion" DeYoung
Come Sail Away" DeYoung
Castle Walls" DeYoung
I'm O.K." DeYoung
The Message" (DeYoung
Lords of the Ring" DeYoung
Queen of Spades" DeYoung
Pieces of Eight" DeYoung

That's 8 Songs they are stealing

and by that logic dennis only steals three

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 7:17 am**

Born4adventure wrote:
froy wrote:
"StyxCollector"

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs.

Yea what about the Dennis songs?

The Grand Illusion" DeYoung
Come Sail Away" DeYoung
Castle Walls" DeYoung
I'm O.K." DeYoung
The Message" (DeYoung
Lords of the Ring" DeYoung
Queen of Spades" DeYoung
Pieces of Eight" DeYoung

That's 8 Songs they are stealing

and by that logic dennis only steals three

Froy also failed to mention that im ok/queen of spades are co writes

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 7:26 am**

Born4adventure wrote:
froy wrote:
"StyxCollector"

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs.

Yea what about the Dennis songs?

The Grand Illusion" DeYoung
Come Sail Away" DeYoung
Castle Walls" DeYoung
I'm O.K." DeYoung
The Message" (DeYoung
Lords of the Ring" DeYoung
Queen of Spades" DeYoung
Pieces of Eight" DeYoung

That's 8 Songs they are stealing

and by that logic dennis only steals three

Far from 8 wouldn't ya say

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 7:31 am**

froy wrote:
Born4adventure wrote:
froy wrote:
"StyxCollector"

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs.

Yea what about the Dennis songs?

The Grand Illusion" DeYoung
Come Sail Away" DeYoung
Castle Walls" DeYoung
I'm O.K." DeYoung
The Message" (DeYoung
Lords of the Ring" DeYoung
Queen of Spades" DeYoung
Pieces of Eight" DeYoung

That's 8 Songs they are stealing

and by that logic dennis only steals three

Far from 8 wouldn't ya say

a lot of those dennis songs that only credit dennis as the writer had large parts from jy and tommy

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 7:36 am**

"a lot of those dennis songs that only credit dennis as the writer had large parts from jy and tommy"

And vice-versa. Ask Tommy what Renegade would have sounded like without Dennis' input????

And don't forget that Dennis pretty much produced BOTH of these albums but gave credit to Styx as the producer when in reality it was him.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 7:43 am**

[quo

te="Born4adventure"]
froy wrote:
Born4adventure wrote:
froy wrote:
"StyxCollector"

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs.

Yea what about the Dennis songs?

The Grand Illusion" DeYoung
Come Sail Away" DeYoung
Castle Walls" DeYoung
I'm O.K." DeYoung
The Message" (DeYoung
Lords of the Ring" DeYoung
Queen of Spades" DeYoung
Pieces of Eight" DeYoung

That's 8 Songs they are stealing

and by that logic dennis only steals three

Far from 8 wouldn't ya say

a lot of those dennis songs that only credit dennis as the writer had large parts from jy and tommy

[/quote]

Sure after he brought the song to them

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 7:52 am**

froy wrote:[quo
te="Born4adventure"]
froy wrote:
Born4adventure wrote:
froy wrote:
"StyxCollector"

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs.

Yea what about the Dennis songs?

The Grand Illusion" DeYoung
Come Sail Away" DeYoung
Castle Walls" DeYoung
I'm O.K." DeYoung
The Message" (DeYoung
Lords of the Ring" DeYoung
Queen of Spades" DeYoung
Pieces of Eight" DeYoung

That's 8 Songs they are stealing

and by that logic dennis only steals three

Far from 8 wouldn't ya say

a lot of those dennis songs that only credit dennis as the writer had large parts from jy and tommy

Sure after he brought the song to them[/quote]

no actually

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 8:10 am**

Wow. Awesome. It's nice to come in here and read something different for a change...

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 8:30 am**

brywool wrote:Wow. Awesome. It's nice to come in here and read something different for a change...

I have an idea lets have STYX do an entire concert of Dennis DeYoung songs
Let's just blow the entire thing up and lets do a show of only Dennis songs
Babe First Time Roboto all of them what do you say,
This way they can pretend he is still in the band just copied by Gowan

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 8:40 am**

OMG............ really everyone?

When I interviewed Dennis and JY at separate times they BOTH said that MAJORITY if not ALL of the Styx songs were written together on the Grand Illusion album. As for the other albums, I'll have to find the sources to back me up before I say anything about those. We all know about the later albums.

There are only a few "true" Styx fans that understand this on here, seriously.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 9:07 am**

And that's why it is the band's best album. Along with P08. The two albums where Dennis, Tommy and JY worked brilliantly together.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 9:23 am**

cittadeeno23 wrote:And that's why it is the band's best album. Along with P08. The two albums where Dennis, Tommy and JY worked brilliantly together.

Exactly and 2 cds that should only be performed by all 3 members

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 9:58 am**

Exactly and 2 cds that should only be performed by all 3 members

I agree. It would be so cool to hear Dennis sing Castle Walls, Tommy sing Man in the Wilderness and JY sing Great White Hope
ALL in the same show. I don't think that has ever happened on the same night.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 12:08 pm**

StyxCollector wrote:
Bearded Clam wrote:I thought they were playing both albums in their entirety?

Froy's trying to make a statement about the DDY songs. Think about it.

D'oh! I've been Froylined.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 12:18 pm**

SuiteMadameBlue wrote:OMG............ really everyone?

When I interviewed Dennis and JY at separate times they BOTH said that MAJORITY if not ALL of the Styx songs were written together on the Grand Illusion album. As for the other albums, I'll have to find the sources to back me up before I say anything about those. We all know about the later albums.

There are only a few "true" Styx fans that understand this on here, seriously.

Even if Member A or Member B were listed as the sole songwriter, everyone contributed. Most bands worked that way at one point or another. Pieces of Eight was largely written the same way.

It's clear on Cornerstone everyone went away and did their own thing.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 12:38 pm**

1. Great White Hope
2. I'm OK
3. Sing For The Day
4. The Message
5. Lords of the Ring
6. Blue Collar Man
7. Queen of Spades
8. Renegade
9. Pieces of Eight
10. Aku-Aku
11. Lorelei
12. Crystal Ball

INTERMISSION

1. Grand Illusion
2. Fooling Yourself
3. Superstars
4. Come Sail Away
5. Miss America
6. Man In The Wilderness
7. Castle Walls
8. Grand Finale

Encore

9. Suite Madame Blue
10. Difference In The World
11. Too Much Time On My Hands

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 1:05 pm**

Mr JY Roboto wrote:
1. Great White Hope
3. Sing For The Day
6. Blue Collar Man
8. Renegade
10. Aku-Aku
12. Crystal Ball

INTERMISSION
2. Fooling Yourself
3. Superstars
5. Miss America
6. Man In The Wilderness
8. Grand Finale

Encore

10. Difference In The World
11. Too Much Time On My Hands

That's better

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 3:04 pm**

froy wrote:
Mr JY Roboto wrote:
1. Great White Hope
2. I'm OK
3. Sing For The Day
4. The Message
5. Lords of the Ring
6. Blue Collar Man
7. Queen of Spades
8. Renegade
9. Pieces of Eight
10. Aku-Aku
11. Babe
12. The Best of Times
13. Don't Let It End

INTERMISSION
1. Grand Illusion
2. Fooling Yourself
3. Superstars
4. Come Sail Away
5. Miss America
6. Man In The Wilderness
7. Castle Walls
8. Grand Finale
9. Mr. Roboto
10. First Time

Encore

11. Why Me
12. Nothing Ever Goes As Planned
13. Too Much Time On My Hands

That's better. I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 5:12 pm**

StyxCollector wrote:
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:OMG............ really everyone?

When I interviewed Dennis and JY at separate times they BOTH said that MAJORITY if not ALL of the Styx songs were written together on the Grand Illusion album. As for the other albums, I'll have to find the sources to back me up before I say anything about those. We all know about the later albums.

There are only a few "true" Styx fans that understand this on here, seriously.

Even if Member A or Member B were listed as the sole songwriter, everyone contributed. Most bands worked that way at one point or another. Pieces of Eight was largely written the same way.

It's clear on Cornerstone everyone went away and did their own thing.

I think some of the band member's comments about song writing contributions were made from a "politically correct" stand point. If I remember correctly, a band member had said that JY was always the last to bring songs to the table for a project and even then his contributions needed the most work. So I think more credit was given to JY then what truly was the case.

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 7:29 am**

Mr JY Roboto"

I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!

Not even going to comment

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 8:18 am**

Mr. JY Roboto Said: "I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!"

WHY??? Seriously, WHY??? Why can't you wait to hear someone who had absolutely NOTHING to do with those songs sing them?
Especially when the person who actually wrote and sang them has one of the greatest voices in rock history.
I'm just curious as to what you are thinking.

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 8:45 am**

froy wrote:
Mr JY Roboto"

I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!

Not even going to comment

That's a first

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:05 am**

cittadeeno23 wrote:Mr. JY Roboto Said: "I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!"

WHY??? Seriously, WHY??? Why can't you wait to hear someone who had absolutely NOTHING to do with those songs sing them?
Especially when the person who actually wrote and sang them has one of the greatest voices in rock history.
I'm just curious as to what you are thinking.

dennis just fools you into thinking he's one of the greatest with his loop do doos

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:17 am**

cittadeeno23 wrote:Mr. JY Roboto Said: "I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!"

WHY??? Seriously, WHY??? Why can't you wait to hear someone who had absolutely NOTHING to do with those songs sing them?
Especially when the person who actually wrote and sang them has one of the greatest voices in rock history.
I'm just curious as to what you are thinking.

I guess I shouldn't post anything sarcastic.

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:26 am**

Born4adventure wrote:
cittadeeno23 wrote:Mr. JY Roboto Said: "I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!"

WHY??? Seriously, WHY??? Why can't you wait to hear someone who had absolutely NOTHING to do with those songs sing them?
Especially when the person who actually wrote and sang them has one of the greatest voices in rock history.
I'm just curious as to what you are thinking.

dennis just fools you into thinking he's one of the greatest with his loop do doos

Chickenbeef needs to be re banned Andrew

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 10:16 am**

froy wrote:
Mr JY Roboto"

I can't wait to hear Gowan sing those songs!!!!!!!!

Not even going to comment

Why dignify it.

MR

Setlist for the Grand 8 Tour

Setlist for the Grand 8 Tour

Grand Illusion

Re: Grand Illusion

The True Set List

Re: The True Set List

Re: The True Set List

Re: The True Set List

Re: The True Set List

Re: The True Set List