MR

from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

It won't. DDY won't approve that.

Toph wrote:

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

It won't. DDY won't approve that.

Not necessarily......weirder things have happened

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

Probably by next spring

Allan/Sterling any news?????

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

It's going to be awhile. They have to have JY go into the studio and over dub his vocals with the use of AutoTune.

Boomchild wrote:

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

It's going to be awhile. They have to have JY go into the studio and over dub his vocals with the use of AutoTune.

Everett wrote:

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

Probably by next spring

Allan/Sterling any news?????

I don't want to talk out of turn, but I don't think they would have bothered filming it unless he had already given his permissions. That's my understanding of it, at least, though it's officially unconfirmed at this time.

Sterling

Babyblue wrote:

Boomchild wrote:

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

It's going to be awhile. They have to have JY go into the studio and over dub his vocals with the use of AutoTune.

Hit a nerve did I??

AutoTune isn't the problem... He's in tune, but his voice is thrashed. A.T. won't help that. Re-cutting the vocals is all that can be done.

Boomchild wrote:

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

any info regarding when the live dvd will be released, can't find a release date anywhere yet, happy new year

It's going to be awhile. They have to have JY go into the studio and over dub his vocals with the use of AutoTune.

cool......then it will be like 99% of every other DVD or live cd that any of us have owned are.

from nick,

is this still going to be released? can't find any information

artinis1 wrote:from nick,

is this still going to be released? can't find any information

They will wait till their summer tour to release it so they can sell for $40 a pop to all the suckers.

I am also interested in this information

I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.

[quote="Baron Von Bielski"]I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.[/quote]


You aren't hearing anything because Deyoung won't let it happen.

Toph wrote:

Baron Von Bielski wrote:I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.

You aren't hearing anything because Deyoung won't let it happen.

According to Tommy, they were going to work on the mix during the current small break. Foo.

Toph wrote:

Baron Von Bielski wrote:I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.

You aren't hearing anything because Deyoung won't let it happen.

news flash tophie they don't need his permission. This ain't journey

i'm guessing that it will be a fall release. it's perfect as a stocking stuffer. and there is talk of a full 2012 GI/PO8 tour, so this would be a good opportunity to create a buzz... who knows.

Toph wrote:

Baron Von Bielski wrote:I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.

You aren't hearing anything because Deyoung won't let it happen.

We have heard about it though... like Mr JY Roboto said. I was merely letting all the people "who actually care" know my thoughts on the matter and a loose timeline to follow. DeYoung can't stop the release.

Baron Von Bielski wrote:

Toph wrote:

Baron Von Bielski wrote:I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.

You aren't hearing anything because Deyoung won't let it happen.

We have heard about it though... like Mr JY Roboto said. I was merely letting all the people "who actually care" know my thoughts on the matter and a loose timeline to follow. DeYoung can't stop the release.

Everett wrote:news flash tophie they don't need his permission. This ain't journey

Sigh. We've been down this road. Yes he can stop it (see the million threads where we've talked about how sync'ing video to audio is problematic and getting rights). This has nothing to do with band politics, but how things work legally. I swear people here have short memories.

That said, as far as I know he won't stop this one. So if it comes out, DDY did approve the use of his songs and he'll get his appropriate cut of this since they're using his songs.

stmonkeys wrote:i'm guessing that it will be a fall release. it's perfect as a stocking stuffer. and there is talk of a full 2012 GI/PO8 tour, so this would be a good opportunity to create a buzz... who knows.

This makes the most sense of all the various guesses out there.


Bugsy

Everett wrote:

Toph wrote:

Baron Von Bielski wrote:I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.

You aren't hearing anything because Deyoung won't let it happen.

news flash tophie they don't need his permission. This ain't journey

You are 100% wrong. They do need his permission

If Dennis approves it - could this be a crack in the ice?

StyxCollector wrote:

Baron Von Bielski wrote:

Toph wrote:

Baron Von Bielski wrote:I look at it this way. One with Everything with CYO took roughly 6 months from it's filming till it's actual DVD release. So, we have a couple of months before wondering where it's at.

You aren't hearing anything because Deyoung won't let it happen.

We have heard about it though... like Mr JY Roboto said. I was merely letting all the people "who actually care" know my thoughts on the matter and a loose timeline to follow. DeYoung can't stop the release.

Everett wrote:news flash tophie they don't need his permission. This ain't journey

Sigh. We've been down this road. Yes he can stop it (see the million threads where we've talked about how sync'ing video to audio is problematic and getting rights). This has nothing to do with band politics, but how things work legally. I swear people here have short memories.

That said, as far as I know he won't stop this one. So if it comes out, DDY did approve the use of his songs and he'll get his appropriate cut of this since they're using his songs.

Ahh, but what I said was not incorrect. I said he couldn't stop the release, and I'm right. He could only have the songs that he wrote not appear on the release. That was my only point. Not to get into or start a debate about copyright law.

Ash wrote:If Dennis approves it - could this be a crack in the ice?

I would think it would take a lot more then that to crack the ice over the River Styx.

I don't know bands fail to recognize that fans want official concert DVDs from back in the day. We want a GI show from the 70s, and a Po8 show from back then....fuck! Is this so tough to grasp? Same with Journey and ROR, or Evolution, Departure, and Infinity.

S2M wrote:I don't know bands fail to recognize that fans want official concert DVDs from back in the day. We want a GI show from the 70s, and a Po8 show from back then....fuck! Is this so tough to grasp? Same with Journey and ROR, or Evolution, Departure, and Infinity.

Or First,Look into the future and Next.

Baron Von Bielski wrote:Ahh, but what I said was not incorrect. I said he couldn't stop the release, and I'm right. He could only have the songs that he wrote not appear on the release. That was my only point. Not to get into or start a debate about copyright law.

So what would be the effing point of a GI/Po8 DVD with about half (or more) of the songs missing? There is none. So for this particular release, they needed DDY's approval. They have certainly released stuff before w/o DDY tunes that he needed to sign off on (Arch Allies, CYO, etc.). So for this release, it's a whole different ballgame.

Ash wrote:If Dennis approves it - could this be a crack in the ice?

No.

StyxCollector wrote: So if it comes out, DDY did approve the use of his songs and he'll get his appropriate cut of this since they're using his songs.

Think about it. They're not idiots. They wouldn't have invested the money if they didn't have the clearances to release it.

They will release it with Denny's compositions intact. It simply wouldn't make any sense to release a live DVD of these 2 albums with half of the material missing.

One With Everything was a different animal. They were approached by the CYO to do a DVD. In that case they kept it simple and didn't include Denny's compositions