Moderator: Andrew
FormerDJMike wrote:Boomchild 7,000 or so hits. This Is The Time (official video 10,500) As for Call Me, while WE know the song the general population does not. It just isn't a recognizable song.

Boomchild wrote:With regards to why Call Me has never been on DDY's set list is due to the fact that other then Desert Moon none of his solo material ever charted on Billboard well. He is going to play mostly Styx material anyway since he known mainly for that. I think DM is thrown in there because that was a semi hit for him, well known and the video got quite a bit of positive airplay on MTV.
Toph wrote:Call Me went to #6 on the Adult Contemporary Chart in 1986 and the video also got decent airplay. It would be one of those songs that people who were in high school back then would hear and after a minute or so would recognize and say, "Man, I haven't heard this song in forever!"
Desert Moon was hardly a "semi-hit." It was pretty damn huge and clearly a big hit. Went to #10 on the Billboard Top 100 chart. Bigger hit than many Styx singles.
Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Call Me went to #6 on the Adult Contemporary Chart in 1986 and the video also got decent airplay. It would be one of those songs that people who were in high school back then would hear and after a minute or so would recognize and say, "Man, I haven't heard this song in forever!"
Desert Moon was hardly a "semi-hit." It was pretty damn huge and clearly a big hit. Went to #10 on the Billboard Top 100 chart. Bigger hit than many Styx singles.
That's all well and good but it comes down to what DDY is mainly known for. Which is his material from Styx. If his solo material would sell concert tickets, I'm sure he would be performing them. To the general public DDY is mainly known for being a member of Styx and not a solo artist. Hence his branding of "The Music of Styx". All the statistics are moot since it comes down to DDY is going choose what he wants to play. So it seems that DDY feels Call Me is not memorable enough to have it in the set list.
Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:With regards to why Call Me has never been on DDY's set list is due to the fact that other then Desert Moon none of his solo material ever charted on Billboard well. He is going to play mostly Styx material anyway since he known mainly for that. I think DM is thrown in there because that was a semi hit for him, well known and the video got quite a bit of positive airplay on MTV.
Call Me went to #6 on the Adult Contemporary Chart in 1986 and the video also got decent airplay. It would be one of those songs that people who were in high school back then would hear and after a minute or so would recognize and say, "Man, I haven't heard this song in forever!"
Desert Moon was hardly a "semi-hit." It was pretty damn huge and clearly a big hit. Went to #10 on the Billboard Top 100 chart. Bigger hit than many Styx singles.
masque wrote:Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:With regards to why Call Me has never been on DDY's set list is due to the fact that other then Desert Moon none of his solo material ever charted on Billboard well. He is going to play mostly Styx material anyway since he known mainly for that. I think DM is thrown in there because that was a semi hit for him, well known and the video got quite a bit of positive airplay on MTV.
Call Me went to #6 on the Adult Contemporary Chart in 1986 and the video also got decent airplay. It would be one of those songs that people who were in high school back then would hear and after a minute or so would recognize and say, "Man, I haven't heard this song in forever!"
Desert Moon was hardly a "semi-hit." It was pretty damn huge and clearly a big hit. Went to #10 on the Billboard Top 100 chart. Bigger hit than many Styx singles.
dude I love "call me" and I'm not a big straight ballad guy.....but i do think that song was great.........but I do not remember that song actually going to #10 on the hot 100 singles chart? was that position like A/C or something? or do you mean the actual hot singles chart?
yogi wrote:I wonder if A&M pulled the plug on that song however that works. It was all over the radio in Mpls/St Paul for about 4 weeks. They played it constantly then puffff it was gone.
Never really liked it that much but it went from being far far overplayed to a complete disappearing act. A&M ? ?
Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Call Me went to #6 on the Adult Contemporary Chart in 1986 and the video also got decent airplay. It would be one of those songs that people who were in high school back then would hear and after a minute or so would recognize and say, "Man, I haven't heard this song in forever!"
Desert Moon was hardly a "semi-hit." It was pretty damn huge and clearly a big hit. Went to #10 on the Billboard Top 100 chart. Bigger hit than many Styx singles.
That's all well and good but it comes down to what DDY is mainly known for. Which is his material from Styx. If his solo material would sell concert tickets, I'm sure he would be performing them. To the general public DDY is mainly known for being a member of Styx and not a solo artist. Hence his branding of "The Music of Styx". All the statistics are moot since it comes down to DDY is going choose what he wants to play. So it seems that DDY feels Call Me is not memorable enough to have it in the set list.
Not saying that DDY isn't better known for his Styx material. But I am saying that Desert Moon is a very recognizable song from the mid 80s. My guess is that most people know that song who were in their formative years in the mid 80s. Call Me, while more of a regional/AC song certainly has some following as evidenced by its 300,000K hits on YouTube and its #3 ranking in DDY's solo iTunes popularity (#2 is It's in Everyone of Us - don't ask me why), tied with Don't Wait For Heroes. My point is that DDY could do Desert Moon and one "deep track" from his solo career that die hards and potentially some mainstream listeners WOULD recognize. I would argue that he could do a rotation of Call Me and DWFH as a second solo song in the set list (one night one, the next night the other) and be perfectly fine. Heck maybe even add SOMETHING from OYFN since it was somewhat critically acclaimed by the fan base and those rock critics that reviewed the record.
I understand the need to play the "sweet 16" but I don't think fans would mind if some variety was put in - not a lot - I'm talking one song here.
Toph wrote:Not true. I never said "mix in a bunch of solo songs." I said add one solo song you illiterate twerp. And your analogy is stupid and makes no sense. Styx is touring as Styx. Not Tommy Shaw. If Tommy Shaw was touring solo, I would expect to see some Styx songs, a solo song or two, and maybe a Damn Yankee song or two.
Monker wrote:Toph wrote:Not true. I never said "mix in a bunch of solo songs." I said add one solo song you illiterate twerp. And your analogy is stupid and makes no sense. Styx is touring as Styx. Not Tommy Shaw. If Tommy Shaw was touring solo, I would expect to see some Styx songs, a solo song or two, and maybe a Damn Yankee song or two.
Is so true. You mentioned Call Me, Dessert Moon, Don't Wait For Heroes, and let's throw in some from OYFN. I know you mentioned one song and rotate and such....it doesn't matter, the people go to see Styx not all of these DDY solo songs.
Your criticism of my analogy is ignorant since DDY is no longer advertised as a DDY solo show. It is advertised as "The Music of Styx". And, you and Dennis BOTH say his latest recording is the best mix of Styx music available. From the time he added a JY and Tommy replacement he ceased being a solo concert and started being an alternate Styx concert. YOU have argued that point for years now. He is giving the audience what they want...what they want is STYX, not DDY solo stuff.
Styx is touring as Styx and DDY is touring as "The Music of Styx". Therefore, if you think Styx performing Tommy solo songs are out of place then you believing DDY perform solo songs at a "Music of Styx" concert is hypocritical at best.
But, hey, it doesn't really matter. My point has been proven by history because DDY *FAILED* to make a go out of making things into a solo DDY show and instead can only tour by making himself into an alternative Styx concert. If he could go on tour as a solo artist - he would. I have no doubt about that.
Toph wrote:Not saying that DDY isn't better known for his Styx material. But I am saying that Desert Moon is a very recognizable song from the mid 80s. My guess is that most people know that song who were in their formative years in the mid 80s. Call Me, while more of a regional/AC song certainly has some following as evidenced by its 300,000K hits on YouTube and its #3 ranking in DDY's solo iTunes popularity (#2 is It's in Everyone of Us - don't ask me why), tied with Don't Wait For Heroes. My point is that DDY could do Desert Moon and one "deep track" from his solo career that die hards and potentially some mainstream listeners WOULD recognize. I would argue that he could do a rotation of Call Me and DWFH as a second solo song in the set list (one night one, the next night the other) and be perfectly fine. Heck maybe even add SOMETHING from OYFN since it was somewhat critically acclaimed by the fan base and those rock critics that reviewed the record.
I understand the need to play the "sweet 16" but I don't think fans would mind if some variety was put in - not a lot - I'm talking one song here.
Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Not saying that DDY isn't better known for his Styx material. But I am saying that Desert Moon is a very recognizable song from the mid 80s. My guess is that most people know that song who were in their formative years in the mid 80s. Call Me, while more of a regional/AC song certainly has some following as evidenced by its 300,000K hits on YouTube and its #3 ranking in DDY's solo iTunes popularity (#2 is It's in Everyone of Us - don't ask me why), tied with Don't Wait For Heroes. My point is that DDY could do Desert Moon and one "deep track" from his solo career that die hards and potentially some mainstream listeners WOULD recognize. I would argue that he could do a rotation of Call Me and DWFH as a second solo song in the set list (one night one, the next night the other) and be perfectly fine. Heck maybe even add SOMETHING from OYFN since it was somewhat critically acclaimed by the fan base and those rock critics that reviewed the record.
I understand the need to play the "sweet 16" but I don't think fans would mind if some variety was put in - not a lot - I'm talking one song here.
Again, it all comes down to DDY is going to perform the songs he wants to and what he thinks will work best for the show. Evidently, the songs you are pointing out here besides DM, DDY feels are not known well enough to include them. You could always post something about these songs to his FB page and see if he responds to it.
Toph wrote:Good point. I do like how he will sometimes respond to people's questions.
Toph wrote:Monker wrote:Toph wrote:Not true. I never said "mix in a bunch of solo songs." I said add one solo song you illiterate twerp. And your analogy is stupid and makes no sense. Styx is touring as Styx. Not Tommy Shaw. If Tommy Shaw was touring solo, I would expect to see some Styx songs, a solo song or two, and maybe a Damn Yankee song or two.
Is so true. You mentioned Call Me, Dessert Moon, Don't Wait For Heroes, and let's throw in some from OYFN. I know you mentioned one song and rotate and such....it doesn't matter, the people go to see Styx not all of these DDY solo songs.
Your criticism of my analogy is ignorant since DDY is no longer advertised as a DDY solo show. It is advertised as "The Music of Styx". And, you and Dennis BOTH say his latest recording is the best mix of Styx music available. From the time he added a JY and Tommy replacement he ceased being a solo concert and started being an alternate Styx concert. YOU have argued that point for years now. He is giving the audience what they want...what they want is STYX, not DDY solo stuff.
Styx is touring as Styx and DDY is touring as "The Music of Styx". Therefore, if you think Styx performing Tommy solo songs are out of place then you believing DDY perform solo songs at a "Music of Styx" concert is hypocritical at best.
But, hey, it doesn't really matter. My point has been proven by history because DDY *FAILED* to make a go out of making things into a solo DDY show and instead can only tour by making himself into an alternative Styx concert. If he could go on tour as a solo artist - he would. I have no doubt about that.
Once again, you prove yourself as an idiot. You contradict yourself so often its hilarious. I said take Desert Moon and rotate 1 other solo song. How does that mean I am advocating for Dennis to play an entire solo set? You put words in people's mouth to suit your agenda. Quite like JY and quite pathetic.
Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Good point. I do like how he will sometimes respond to people's questions.
I'm surprised how active he has been on his FB page recently based on his comments\feelings in the past about the internet in general.
Monker wrote:But, hey, it doesn't really matter. My point has been proven by history because DDY *FAILED* to make a go out of making things into a solo DDY show and instead can only tour by making himself into an alternative
Toph wrote:Monker - You are a fucking moron and just like to stir the proverbial bathwater. I never said replace Crystal Ball or Renegade with a Dennis solo song. And you are dead wrong about Desert Moon. That is a song that always generates significant audience reaction - arguably more than Crystal Ball.
I've seen DDY 5 times. How many times have you? That's what I thought. Fucking tool.
Boomchild wrote:Monker wrote:But, hey, it doesn't really matter. My point has been proven by history because DDY *FAILED* to make a go out of making things into a solo DDY show and instead can only tour by making himself into an alternative
This is not an accurate picture. From the time Dennis started doing his shows post being ejected from Styx he has billed himself as Dennis DeYoung and The Music of Styx. All you need to do is look to the first shows at the Chicago Theater. Also, early on was the show taped for Soundstage and that was also billed as the "Music of Styx". If you focus on the content of the actual shows from the very beginning, the majority of songs were from Styx. Sure, the number of solo songs have been striped back to one at this point.
Monker wrote:Toph wrote:Monker - You are a fucking moron and just like to stir the proverbial bathwater. I never said replace Crystal Ball or Renegade with a Dennis solo song. And you are dead wrong about Desert Moon. That is a song that always generates significant audience reaction - arguably more than Crystal Ball.
LOL. You talk about being a moron and then say things that never happened. I never said that you said blah, blah, blah. Wierdo.
Nobody would care if he dropped Desert Moon. He could easily replace it with a Styx song. Maybe Snowblind. Nobody would know or care.I've seen DDY 5 times. How many times have you? That's what I thought. Fucking tool.
Oh, wow, you had a thought. I wonder what thought it is that you thought?
Does it count seeing Dennis on PBS promoting his orchestra live album and trying to get a PBS Hunchback production some support?
Monker wrote:Boomchild wrote:Monker wrote:But, hey, it doesn't really matter. My point has been proven by history because DDY *FAILED* to make a go out of making things into a solo DDY show and instead can only tour by making himself into an alternative
This is not an accurate picture. From the time Dennis started doing his shows post being ejected from Styx he has billed himself as Dennis DeYoung and The Music of Styx. All you need to do is look to the first shows at the Chicago Theater. Also, early on was the show taped for Soundstage and that was also billed as the "Music of Styx". If you focus on the content of the actual shows from the very beginning, the majority of songs were from Styx. Sure, the number of solo songs have been striped back to one at this point.
EXACTLY...one solo song. Compare that to when her first started out where he not only did some solo songs but a few songs directly from Hunchback It was a DDY solo show that had Styx songs. THAT FAILED. Now it is just DDY's version of Styx. If you can't see and admit that, you're in denial.
Monker wrote:
EXACTLY...one solo song. Compare that to when her first started out where he not only did some solo songs but a few songs directly from Hunchback It was a DDY solo show that had Styx songs. THAT FAILED. Now it is just DDY's version of Styx. If you can't see and admit that, you're in denial.
Monker wrote:Your criticism of my analogy is ignorant since DDY is no longer advertised as a DDY solo show. It is advertised as "The Music of Styx".
Users browsing this forum: Majestic-12 [Bot] and 6 guests