Your final opinion on re-recorded Greatest Hits!

by **RebornJrny** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:22 am

I'm not trying to beat a dead horse regarding these re-recording issue, but just curious about this poll on number of fans who like/dislike these re-recordings.
I just want to see numbers. After a controversial decision made by Journey to re-record these GH, Journey fans were divided about this issue, do you think Journey/Walmart made the right or made a very stupid decision releasing these re-recorded hits? Here are your poll options.

by **Saint John** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:29 am

There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some of them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

by **RebornJrny** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:31 am

Saint John wrote:There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

But do you want to hear more re-records in the future?

by **Lula** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:32 am

#2 for me and that goes for the new stuff as well.

by **RebornJrny** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:33 am

Lula wrote:#2 for me and that goes for the new stuff as well.

Thanks, Lula

by **Rick** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:34 am

RebornJrny wrote:
Saint John wrote:There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

But do you want to hear more re-records in the future?

This kid kinda looks like his pappa, huh?

by **Saint John** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:36 am

RebornJrny wrote:
Saint John wrote:There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

But do you want to hear more re-records in the future?

Sure. I don't think it can hurt anything or anyone. Steve Perry's legacy as a lead singer is signed, sealed and delivered. I think re-recording music from his time in the band only showcases just how great he was and also serves as a link to the present.

by **RebornJrny** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:36 am

Rick wrote:
RebornJrny wrote:
Saint John wrote:There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

But do you want to hear more re-records in the future?

This kid kinda looks like his pappa, huh?

No shit Rick, where'd you found that picture?

by **RebornJrny** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:41 am

Saint John wrote:
RebornJrny wrote:
Saint John wrote:There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

But do you want to hear more re-records in the future?

Sure. I don't think it can hurt anything or anyone. Steve Perry's legacy as a lead singer is signed, sealed and delivered. I think re-recording music from his time in the band only showcases just how great he was and also serves as a link to the present.

Agreed, I've talked to some of my friends, and they're mostly casual fans, I showed them their new CD and their first to request to hear are the re-recorded songs and they were all surprised how good Arnel is.

by **tammy** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 10:05 am

I only just listened to the re-records yesterday...well, half way thru and then had enough. I won't listen to them again - the SP originals are perfect.

And, I prefer SA's version of FITH, especially with beginning and ending (which is super).
When I heard DSB start on the re-records it sounded weird - I think somebody here said it sounded like JC was playing a Fisher-Price toy piano & it did. AP does a fine job and I certainly wouldn't want to go to a Journey concert and hear ca-ca, but leave the originals on CD alone from now on.

I just prefer an artist create their own original work. I do love the new songs.

by **Rick** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 10:06 am

RebornJrny wrote:
Rick wrote:
RebornJrny wrote:
Saint John wrote:There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

But do you want to hear more re-records in the future?

This kid kinda looks like his pappa, huh?

No shit Rick, where'd you found that picture?

At this website.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/madpod/2395654629/

by **cookieduster** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 10:17 am

No thanks, I'll stick with the originals. I think FITH is better by Steve Augeri as well.

by **ymsf** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 10:39 am

I think this CD is totally not necessary, but at least it's 'free' (in a sense that it's a bonus).

by **Red13JoePa** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:18 am

A+ of course, for me.
They sound terrific now.

by **G.I.Jim** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:27 am

I think they did great on the re-records. A couple of things that really bother me though, is Jon's cheesy sounding key parts (Don't Stop Believing, Separate Ways), and that damn click track during "Faithfully" and "Open Arms"! I know they were just rushed, and those things were just overlooked though. I just wish they could have spent a little more time on them (as well as the new songs) and polish them just a tad. Overall, I'm happy as hell with it!

by **Deb** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:30 am

Rick wrote:
RebornJrny wrote:
Saint John wrote:There's really no choice for me listed. I'll listen to them every once in awhile. I like some them a lot and others not so much. I guess I'm stuck somewhere between the first two choices but probably a bit closer to the second one.

But do you want to hear more re-records in the future?

This kid kinda looks like his pappa, huh?

Is that Miles? Wow, does he ever! :shock:

by **Saint John** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:31 am

That kid's gonna get a lot of ass.

by **4ever4Steve** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:35 am

Well, I think most are very, very good ,esp. "Only the Young"...BUT I like Augeri's FITH much better( more emotion and strength of the song's lyrics), and I also think "Stone In Love' was the worst of these re-do's. Arnel sounded tired, or sick or just not 'into' that song at the moment they recorded it.
All in all, I do think Arnel is a great singer, and I love all the new ones ( except WITTW). I now skip that one; just don't like the song.

Peace & Love,
Anne :wink:

by **Voyager** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:35 am

I think the re-records sounded okay, and proved that Arnel is up to the task, but I believe the only thing they accomplished in the long run was to attempt to piss Steve Perry off really bad. I don't picture anyone sitting in front of their CD player saying, "I'm going to toss my Perry/Journey CD's and listen to these instead."

by **Rick** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:39 am

Saint John wrote:That kid's gonna get a lot of ass.

by **Rhiannon** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:50 am

Deb wrote:
Rick wrote:This kid kinda looks like his pappa, huh?

Is that Miles? Wow, does he ever!

Miles is a stone cold fox... :twisted:

by **YankeeRose** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 3:26 pm

I think they are kind of pointless, since they sound almost exactly the same as the originals! They are well done though. I will listen to it once in a while.

by **musicfan17** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 5:17 pm

While I don't want to hear anymore re-records....I think the current ones are fine.

My take is that they give people a chance to hear what the songs will sound like live with Arnel at the helm...cause let's face it...if you go to see Journey live now...this is pretty much what you are going to hear. And I'm very cool with that to be honest. I think Arnel did the songs justice and put his own touch to them. Everyone that I played them for so far has like them, but they think the new stuff is just awesome. So I think it's win win for the Journey boys.

by **Liam** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 5:59 pm

They're AWFUL. I HAD to listen to them a couple of times to give them a "fair shake", but they're just not good, IMO.
I almost chose the "Not interested" choice, but I chose the "They're bad" one. Although, I'd throw the word Pointless in that choice as well. I WILL say that OTY is the best one but it pales in comparison to Perry by a LONGSHOT.

by **Gin and Tonic Sky** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 6:50 pm

I can perfectly enjoy Arnel sinigng the greatest hits live - fine with that and he sounds great.

The re-records different matter, whilst not as bad as I thought they might be are an advertisement that says to the world "Arnels a great singer and is a perfectly legit lead singer of Journey , but will never be a Steve Perry". All of us could already figure that out, not in anyones best interest to keep reminding us!

by **Spike** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 8:57 pm

I selected the "They're bad" option.

It's not that Arnel is particularly bad on them, (although as a singer, he doesn't float my boat) but the production and general care and attention to the playing is absent. Mine certainly won't suffer much wear and tear through playing.

by **jrnyjunky** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 9:18 pm

I have only listened to it once, so I will probably listen a couple more times to give it a chance. My problem is I think of those songs as Steve songs, and I really don't want to hear anyone else sing those songs but Perry.

by **sniper16** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:03 pm

you perry people are funny, quit beating a dead horse, its not like they are really selling these, its a free disc, rerecord everything for christ sakes and give them away for all i care, they new ones arnt bad, treat it like an acoustic thing , and move on

by **Vladan** » Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:06 pm

The production is medicore. The songs are nice for a change, but the sadly sound like a cover band performing good songs, but falling short musically and Vocally. A good effort, but not good enough to be played on the radio...

by **nolippin** » Tue Jun 17, 2008 12:06 am

If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

MR

Your final opinion on re-recorded Greatest Hits!

What's your final opinion on re-recorded GH?

Your final opinion on re-recorded Greatest Hits!

Abiut the re-recordings...

Who is online