knox wrote:He sounded okay, not good. Anyone who struggles that much in a song doesn't sound good, they sound strained, uncomfortable, out of their range.
I winced a couple of times when he tried to go high. He NEVER had the range to do these songs. NEVER. Each time he tries to go up I quiver...
Aaaah, Knoxy, dont agree my friend, I will say that a lot of stuff is at the edge of his range, but he made
all the notes he was asked to reach, right throughout the gig, he didnt fudge any by choosing a "lower" melody line, he went for them all, and got em. Ok, there is a "Power-loss" compromise when hes at the upper limit, but thats just the way it is for a lot of vocal high flyers, take Hugo for instance, he reaches the notes, but the results are very very thin.
After watching all of this gig Ive re evaluated my views of Augeri. He was doing the stuff in his own way at this point, he has a touch of the Perry's for sure, but there is a little something of his own there too. kind of like a Perry meets Chalfant kinda sound. At the end of the day, if you think Augeri wasnt up to it then, you have to throw doubt on Schons, and Cains ability to judge the merits of a fellow pro singer, and I just dont buy that they would go with someone who couldnt do the material any justice, they are far too pro and savvy, as well as experienced to take a "misfit" on board. !!
Pity this gig never made it out of its box, as its a cool testament to the great choice they made in Augeri at that time