MR

Simple folks. This is a test on Joe's intelligence or lack therof and his common sense. Ok?

Butterfly

Complete shit. Embarrassing piece of the catalog. I'd rather listen to Don Imus being butt-fucked by Al Sharpton.

Yea, yea. Whatever Mr Jameson I mean St John.

Now, I, of course picked 4. I see it as a song kinda like Lights or After The Fall or Eyes Of A Woman, that although mild is NOT a ballad.

Matt's terrific at making these kind of distinctions I'd like his opinion on the thing, too.

If he can STAND giving this Augeri-fronted Journey track another listen before weighing in....

PS: You better footnote JR for using his Joemama nickname for me. We know the bastard's looking

Hated that song from the first time I heard it.

Dude, I can write AND sing this piece of shit "song." I could do it upside down while Lulas' dog licks my sweaty ass cheeks....Seriously, complete hack thing.

I knew a thread was gonna be started about this!

Song sucks, big time...

Red13JoePa wrote:Yea, yea. Whatever Mr Jameson I mean St John.

Now, I, of course picked 4. I see it as a song kinda like Lights or After The Fall or Eyes Of A Woman, that although mild is NOT a ballad.

Matt's terrific at making these kind of distinctions I'd like his opinion on the thing, too.

If he can STAND giving this Augeri-fronted Journey track another listen before weighing in....

The 3 songs you mentioned have smooth, soaring vocals, hammer-licker. The shit stain you mentioned does not. When will you accept the fact that Augeri had a mediocre voice and was a blemish on Journey's resume? Please don't compare any of his songs to Perry's. Try a different singer. Lemmy for Motor Head and Sam Kinison immediately come to mind.

Hm, I'm intrigued that the other 3 who didn't go for your obvious propoganda choice #1 DID roll w/ 4 as in "non-ballad."

not every fuckin non-rocker has to be a "ballad."

I voted against the song, but not against Joe13.

worst song ever, by the band

whocares wrote:worst song ever, by the band

Just one of many from Generations...

saint John wrote:The 3 songs you mentioned have smooth, soaring vocals, hammer-licker.

The ever-eloquent St John weighs in. Dude, I'm embaressed beyond BELIEF when I have to tell people I'm actually your friend, because as boorishly effective as you are, you always go and, I dunno FEM it up by blubbering all over the damn joint about perry's "Soaring Vocals ( )."

Dunno what in hell's wrong with you. Gotta toughen this kid up.

JGal wrote:

whocares wrote:worst song ever, by the band

Just one of many from Generations...

Sure there are terrible songs on the MUCH TOO RUSHED Generations. The best one(s?) being sung by the drummer of all people. I personally am glad that I didn't outright (since getting it free at the "live concert"), have to pay for Generations.

Best song on it by far, is A Better Life.

Red13JoePa wrote:

saint John wrote:The 3 songs you mentioned have smooth, soaring vocals, hammer-licker.

The ever-eloquent St John weighs in. Dude, I'm embaressed beyond BELIEF when I have to tell people I'm actually your friend, because as boorishly effective as you are, you always go and, I dunno FEM it up by blubbering all over the damn joint about perry's "Soaring Vocals ( )."

Dunno what in hell's wrong with you. Gotta toughen this kid up.

The vocals on Butterfly sounds like a man with schizophrenia talking to himself. Funny how you're "embaressed" beyond belief, though. Nice spelling.

I gave my secretary the night off, stain. I make salient points about fatal flaws about your very MANhood and all that strikes you is spelling, which NOone gives a shit about. You'll never learn that way.

You make me ashamed to be a Penn State fan.

whocares wrote:

JGal wrote:

whocares wrote:worst song ever, by the band

Just one of many from Generations...

Sure there are terrible songs on the MUCH TOO RUSHED Generations. The best one(s?) being sung by the drummer of all people. I personally am glad that I didn't outright (since getting it free at the "live concert"), have to pay for Generations.

Best song on it by far, is A Better Life.

The only two I can tolerate are FITH & Never Too Late.

All coming out of the woodwork now, all the Generations bashers trying to gimme my medicine for keeping it REAL up the "Loons" thread.

At 1102PM Eastern and 802PM Pacific, Melodicrock.com is calling Butterfly for the Suck ass column...Butterfly goes to the suckass column, and well, it just wasn't close was it folks?

Red13JoePa wrote:All coming out of the woodwork now, all the Generations bashers trying to gimme my medicine for keeping it REAL up the "Loons" thread.

You got rolled.

there's a BIG differnce between a loon and someone who knows a BAD Album by perhaps their favorite band.

Red13JoePa wrote:I gave my secretary the night off, stain. I make salient points about fatal flaws about your very MANhood and all that strikes you is spelling, which NOone gives a shit about. You'll never learn that way.

You make me ashamed to be a Penn State fan.

I think that most would agree that, as it pertains to "manhood," being a fan of Butterfly is MUCH more feminine/faggy than saying Perry, for the most part, was graced with "soaring vocals." Shit, isn't that part of the reason he's nicknamed "The Voice?" What is Augeri's nickname? Deano, care to answer that, sir?

Really bad song. Gay in fact. I have no use for it. Embarassing.

Screw you, too ArrivalRules. I handled all your dirty work, too in the LoonsAlert thread and this is goddam thanks ?

Red13JoePa wrote:Screw you, too ArrivalRules. I handled all your dirty work, too in the LoonsAlert thread and this is goddam thanks ?

I will defend the Arrival CD. Can't do it on Butterfly though. I am consistent.

can you feeeeeel tha looooove toniiiiight....

Actually, I do like Neals guitar on Butterfly. But the rest is shit. Deens tinkering homosexual cymbal work is also embarrassing. I gave him shit for that last February.

AR wrote:

Red13JoePa wrote:Screw you, too ArrivalRules. I handled all your dirty work, too in the LoonsAlert thread and this is goddam thanks ?

I will defend the Arrival CD. Can't do it on Butterfly though. I am consistent.

Oh ok Dorothy Hamill. Shall I start up a poll on that piece of shit CD?

RockinDeano wrote:Dude, I can write AND sing this piece of shit "song." I could do it upside down while Lulas' dog licks my sweaty ass cheeks....Seriously, complete hack thing.

This, I'll agree with you on. The song sucks, big-time!

Generations has bad production values. I do like Place in Your Heart, Better Life, Faith in the Heartland, and Never Too Late a lot though.

So for the Augeri era CD's:

Arrival - like that a lot
Red 13 - nah, no hooks
Generations = spotty. Sonically, it doesn't sound good, but the tracks I mentioned I really like

In the Perry era, I hate Trial By Fire, don't like Raised on Radio much (but love a handfull of tracks off of it)

Love everything else Perry era. Great stuff - the true JRNY recordings!

Perry solos:

Street Talk = AWESOME
For the Love of Strange Medicine = SHIT

Now you know where I stand.

AR wrote:Generations has bad production values. I do like Place in Your Heart, Better Life, Faith in the Heartland, and Never Too Late a lot though.

So for the Augeri era CD's:

Arrival - like that a lot
Red 13 - nah, no hooks
Generations = spotty. Sonically, it doesn't sound good, but the tracks I mentioned I really like

In the Perry era, I hate Trial By Fire, don't like Raised on Radio much (but love a handfull of tracks off of it)

Love everything else Perry era. Great stuff - the true JRNY recordings!

Perry solos:

Street Talk = AWESOME
For the Love of Strange Medicine = SHIT

Now you know where I stand.

Let me guess.....you shove your underwear up your ass, put on sunglasses and prance around like Tom Cruise in Risky Business and sing Positive Touch? Oh wait, that's JoePa!!


PS I like Positive Touch