Page 1 of 2
bands playing entire albums in concert within the setlist
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 7:44 amby mikemarrs
metallica has recently been playing all of master of puppets album in concert.i think a few other bands like queensryche did this too by playing all of operation mindcrime.i think it would be cool if journey played again to start off one night maybe playing the entire infinity album before playing the rest of the setlist.maybe the next night do all of frontiers or escape.that means quite a few obscure songs make it in the setlist.i think its a great idea......
Re: bands playing entire albums in concert within the setlis
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 7:54 amby tj
mikemarrs wrote:metallica has recently been playing all of master of puppets album in concert.i think a few other bands like queensryche did this too by playing all of operation mindcrime.i think it would be cool if journey played again to start off one night maybe playing the entire infinity album before playing the rest of the setlist.maybe the next night do all of frontiers or escape.that means quite a few obscure songs make it in the setlist.i think its a great idea......
I think they tried the obscure songs format at the start of the 30th anniversary tour. Not a whole album, but stuff off the first 3 albums that most of the crowd didn't know or want to hear. I seem to recall Jon or Neal saying that they had to eliminate a bunch of the old stuff because the fans kept going to get more beer, bathroom, etc. until the dirty dozen started.
Re: bands playing entire albums in concert within the setlis
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:04 amby conversationpc
mikemarrs wrote:metallica has recently been playing all of master of puppets album in concert.i think a few other bands like queensryche did this too by playing all of operation mindcrime.i think it would be cool if journey played again to start off one night maybe playing the entire infinity album before playing the rest of the setlist.maybe the next night do all of frontiers or escape.that means quite a few obscure songs make it in the setlist.i think its a great idea......
Queensryche is currently doing all of "Operation: Mindcrime" and "Operation: Mindcrime 2".
Re: bands playing entire albums in concert within the setlis
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:11 amby Carlitto H@kk
conversationpc wrote:Queensryche is currently doing all of "Operation: Mindcrime" and "Operation: Mindcrime 2".
DT has done this before too, even going as far as playing entire Pink Floyd albums
from start to finish
But Ryche rules this idea; OM I and II are masterpieces with
an outstanding storyline... They could make for one hella broadway production
if done right/not watered down.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:17 amby cyndy!
cheap trick did this & more a few years ago. 3 nights in one venue - entire 1st, 2nd & 3rd albums on each night with a Q&A afterwards. one of the coolest things i've ever seen.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:19 amby Rick
Boston did that on the Third Stage tour. I didn't get to see it, but I have a bootleg of it.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:32 amby ProgRocker53
Porcupine Tree played their entire new album at their show in Cleveland on May 17th.
At the Journey show in Cincinnati last year on July 25th, I think they played 7 out of 10 songs on Escape, but not necessarily in order. They did everything off that album but "Mother, Father," "Still They Ride," and "Lay It Down."
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:34 amby piecesofeight
cyndy! wrote:cheap trick did this & more a few years ago. 3 nights in one venue - entire 1st, 2nd & 3rd albums on each night with a Q&A afterwards. one of the coolest things i've ever seen.
Yeah, I have all these shows. Great stuff.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:41 amby Rockindeano
Journey played 7 of 10 for Escape, and 8 of 10 for Frontiers and 4 of ten for ROR. Of those, it was probably a good idea to leave off Dead or Alive, Lay it down, Frontiers, Troubled Child, Once You Love Someone, Could Have Been You, Eyes of a Woman and Happy to Give, don't you think? Those songs, while some decent, aren't exactly heart stoppers.
REO played the first side of Hi Infidelity, in order, in 2003 for the Main Event. That was cool. The thing is nowadays, there is no first side or second side. Can you see Journey coming out to thunderous applause and playing side 2 of Generations?
Every Generation kicks off the set! I have goosebumps...well not really. Friga lip syncing a shitty tune is bad, Mkay.
Believe is next. Fans filing out faster now. The fans that do stay, talk about suing for having to endure such shitty music.
Knowing that You love Me comes......and goes..people are nodding off. The game now is to actually see when Augeri motions to Elson to hit the button. Out of Harms Way is next, and people are still watching Elson work his magic. Better Together is next, and people are watching Neal make those pissed off faces to his sound man...Never happy dwarf is hysterical when he is pissed. The midget's little widget is out of tune. Looks to be taking a dump in his pants. Beyond the Clouds rounds out the set, and the BT ers are swaying back and forth like cute little 2 ton African elephants knee deep in custard filling.
Damn, what a band!
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:49 amby Angiekay
I've seen both Pink Floyd and Roger Waters perform all of Dark Side of The Moon. THAT is an experience!
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 8:53 amby piecesofeight
Queensryche is performing live on Rockline tonight and this is a portion of what the Rockline website said in regard to this-
" Well, where do we start with this one? QUEENSRYCHE IS GOING TO PLAY LIVE ON ROCKLINE! SEVENTY FULL MINUTES PLUGGED IN AND ELECTRIC! There. At least that’s a beginning. The band just enjoyed their first ever Number One Billboard debut with the recent release of the DVD “Mindcrime At The Moore” performing the entire epic in front of a crazed Seattle crowd."
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 9:08 amby Red13JoePa
Soul SirkUs pretty much did it on the World Play tour I saw...course what choice was there, but it kicked my ass sideways anyhow. Peephole live, heavier than an anvil upside the skullpiece.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 9:41 amby WalrusOct9
I think it's a cool idea on paper...but unless it's a concept piece like Mindcrime or Dream Theater's "Scenes From A Memory," I think it's kind of boring.
Part of the fun of concerts is not knowing what's next (which kinda sucks for bands that play the same fucking setlist every single night...Genesis anyone?)...the surprise of hearing an obscure song you love, or the massive crowd euphoria when U2 plays "Streets" or Springsteen launches "Born To Run"...if everyone knew they were coming, I don't think it'd be as cool.
I like the idea of a concert as something completely separate from a studio record...I like that songs that work as 1st tracks on an album can't really be used to open shows, and how some random album track can turn into a breathtaking concert opener or set closer in concert.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 10:49 amby styxfanNH
Brian Wilson did Smile a couple of years ago in its entirety. If a band is going to do it, it should be announced prior to ticketsales. Certainly would be a treat for die hard fans, but may be troublesome for the casual fan. I saw Brian Wilson do Smile. First act was all Beach Boys and they returned for the second act for the entire Smile album.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 4:14 pmby Liam
Angiekay wrote:
I've seen both Pink Floyd and Roger Waters perform all of Dark Side of The Moon. THAT is an experience!
Bad part is...Waters' voice SUCKS. STILL. I'm sure he's gotten some bass lessons in the past 20 years or so...'cause he sucked at that as well. I KNOW that Gilmore is the "Newbie", but he was the best thing that could've happened to that band musically. Lyrically?? Yea..I WILL give that to Waters. AND...I'm one of the fans that hate the Wall as MUCH as the Final Cut. That's a LOT, BTW.
"Lapse" and "Division" are STILL the best Floyd albums to come out since Wish You Were Here. Well...MAYBE Animals.
I'm not bustin' on ya, Angie...just giving my opinion.
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 9:19 pmby NealIsGod
Angiekay wrote:
I've seen both Pink Floyd and Roger Waters perform all of Dark Side of The Moon. THAT is an experience!
Do you mean Pink Floyd WITH Roger Waters, or two separate shows? If it was two shows, which did you prefer?
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 11:25 pmby NoMoreTails
Red13JoePa wrote:Soul SirkUs pretty much did it on the World Play tour I saw...course what choice was there, but it kicked my ass sideways anyhow. Peephole live, heavier than an anvil upside the skullpiece.
I think Coming Home is the only one they didn't play, ever...I think they actually left Peephole out of a couple of their later US shows, I would have been pissed if I'd been at one of those shows.
SS, no longer together, still have a website...JSS is probably footing the bill...
Posted:
Thu Aug 02, 2007 11:39 pmby Red13JoePa
NoMoreTails wrote:I think Coming Home is the only one they didn't play, ever
...and rightfully so.
Ballads did NOT belong in a Soul SirkUs setlist, though suffering through the SHML cover afforded one the opportunity to realize JSS could pull Journey off in a blink if Augeri succumbed.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 12:15 amby Angiekay
NealIsGod wrote:Angiekay wrote:
I've seen both Pink Floyd and Roger Waters perform all of Dark Side of The Moon. THAT is an experience!
Do you mean Pink Floyd WITH Roger Waters, or two separate shows? If it was two shows, which did you prefer?
Two separate shows. I saw Floyd in 94 and Roger Waters last month. Liam is full of shit, Roger sounded just fine. It's a tough call, but I would have to go with Pink Floyd. The Floyd show was outdoors and one of the most amazing shows I've ever been too. Of all the concerts I've been too, it's still in my top three.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 12:17 amby conversationpc
Angiekay wrote:Two separate shows. I saw Floyd in 94 and Roger Waters last month. Liam is full of shit, Roger sounded just fine. It's a tough call, but I would have to go with Pink Floyd. The Floyd show was outdoors and one of the most amazing shows I've ever been too. Of all the concerts I've been too, it's still in my top three.
[/color][/size][/b]
Roger Waters has always been a horrible singer, so him sounding like crap wouldn't be much different than anything he's done in the past. However, I don't listen to Pink Floyd's music to hear good singing. His voice just goes with their music.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 2:27 amby Wally_Hatchet
Dio played most of Magica in 2000. Man, that sucked!
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 3:51 amby Liam
Angiekay wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Angiekay wrote:
I've seen both Pink Floyd and Roger Waters perform all of Dark Side of The Moon. THAT is an experience!
Do you mean Pink Floyd WITH Roger Waters, or two separate shows? If it was two shows, which did you prefer?
Two separate shows. I saw Floyd in 94 and Roger Waters last month. Liam is full of shit, Roger sounded just fine. It's a tough call, but I would have to go with Pink Floyd. The Floyd show was outdoors and one of the most amazing shows I've ever been too. Of all the concerts I've been too, it's still in my top three.
I'm not full of shit...I was giving my opinion. I've never liked Waters' voice. Simple as that.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 4:05 amby 7 Wishes
ProgRocker53 wrote:Porcupine Tree played their entire new album at their show in Cleveland on May 17th.
Decent band, dude, but let's not get them mixed up with the likes of Dream Theater and Queensryche.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 4:10 amby NealIsGod
Liam wrote:Angiekay wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Angiekay wrote:
I've seen both Pink Floyd and Roger Waters perform all of Dark Side of The Moon. THAT is an experience!
Do you mean Pink Floyd WITH Roger Waters, or two separate shows? If it was two shows, which did you prefer?
Two separate shows. I saw Floyd in 94 and Roger Waters last month. Liam is full of shit, Roger sounded just fine. It's a tough call, but I would have to go with Pink Floyd. The Floyd show was outdoors and one of the most amazing shows I've ever been too. Of all the concerts I've been too, it's still in my top three.
I'm not full of shit...I was giving my opinion. I've never liked Waters' voice. Simple as that.
You gotta keep that harem in line, dude.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 4:24 amby 7 Wishes
Waters is arguably the most talented contemporary musician of the latter half of the 20th century. He wrote THE WALL and THE FINAL CUT, for the Love of God.
Don't give me the standard Beatles/Zeppelin response. Lennon/McCartney and Page/Plant were symbiotic, and their solo stuff (with a few exceptions) is not even in the same league as the last two REAL Floyd albums or his four solo records.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 4:24 amby Red13JoePa
Waters sounds like he's about a day younger than God now.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 4:34 amby conversationpc
Naughtius Maximus wrote:Waters is arguably the most talented contemporary musician of the latter half of the 20th century. He wrote THE WALL and THE FINAL CUT, for the Love of God.
Don't give me the standard Beatles/Zeppelin response. Lennon/McCartney and Page/Plant were symbiotic, and their solo stuff (with a few exceptions) is not even in the same league as the last two REAL Floyd albums or his four solo records.
I love "The Division Bell" and "A Momentary Lapse of Reason" just fine. However, I haven't heard "The Final Cut" so I can't compare, but the other two are pretty good.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 5:22 amby Liam
NealIsGod wrote:Liam wrote:Angiekay wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Angiekay wrote:
I've seen both Pink Floyd and Roger Waters perform all of Dark Side of The Moon. THAT is an experience!
Do you mean Pink Floyd WITH Roger Waters, or two separate shows? If it was two shows, which did you prefer?
Two separate shows. I saw Floyd in 94 and Roger Waters last month. Liam is full of shit, Roger sounded just fine. It's a tough call, but I would have to go with Pink Floyd. The Floyd show was outdoors and one of the most amazing shows I've ever been too. Of all the concerts I've been too, it's still in my top three.
I'm not full of shit...I was giving my opinion. I've never liked Waters' voice. Simple as that.
You gotta keep that harem in line, dude.
No kidding, bro. This one's a loose cannon.
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 5:29 amby ArnelRox
RockinDeano wrote: Can you see Journey coming out to thunderous applause and playing side 2 of Generations?
Every Generation kicks off the set! I have goosebumps...well not really. Friga lip syncing a shitty tune is bad, Mkay.
Believe is next. Fans filing out faster now. The fans that do stay, talk about suing for having to endure such shitty music.
Knowing that You love Me comes......and goes..people are nodding off. The game now is to actually see when Augeri motions to Elson to hit the button. Out of Harms Way is next, and people are still watching Elson work his magic. Better Together is next, and people are watching Neal make those pissed off faces to his sound man...Never happy dwarf is hysterical when he is pissed. The midget's little widget is out of tune. Looks to be taking a dump in his pants. Beyond the Clouds rounds out the set, and the BT ers are swaying back and forth like cute little 2 ton African elephants knee deep in custard filling.
Damn, what a band!
Funny shit! LMAO
Posted:
Fri Aug 03, 2007 6:39 amby Classic Rock
Naughtius Maximus wrote:Waters is arguably the most talented contemporary musician of the latter half of the 20th century. He wrote THE WALL and THE FINAL CUT, for the Love of God.
Don't give me the standard Beatles/Zeppelin response. Lennon/McCartney and Page/Plant were symbiotic, and their solo stuff (with a few exceptions) is not even in the same league as the last two REAL Floyd albums or his four solo records.
Last two “real” Pink Floyd records? To me and a lot of Pink Floyd fans out there the last two “real” Pink Floyd records were
Animals &
The Wall.
The Final Cut , while it may be great, is more like a Roger Waters solo album because the other two had very little input and Richard Wright wasn't even in the band anymore. To be honest if I had to choose between
The Final Cut &
The Division Bell I would choose the latter.
I love
The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking &
Radio K.A.O.S because he is not forcing his same old tired left wing political agenda. Hell not even Lennon harped about War as much as he did in songs.