Monker wrote:Voyager wrote:G.I.Jim wrote:Has this place ever been more dead?
It started the Journey forum members were split apart, and it's been downhill ever since. I don't think it will recover. People liked being all together on the Journey forum for some reason. But Neal didn't want people speaking freely about Journey without him controlling what was being said, and MR was the largest Journey forum before the split. Apparently keeping Neal happy is more of a priority than having a kickass Journey forum.

That makes absolutely no sense at all. How does Neal or Journey control the MR forums? If this were journeymusic.com, I would agree, but not here.
I think it's obvious that Andrew split the forums because so much off topic BS was posted in the Journey forum. Why even call it a "Journey" forum when Journey is hardly ever discussed?
The MR Journey forum comes up first when you type in "Journey forum" on Google. Neal and the boys obviously knew how much traffic was coming to it, and they did not like the fact that they couldn't control what was being said about them. I don't know if they ever contacted Andrew directly about it, but I'm sure they weren't too happy about it.
Whenever you split up a large forum, you will lose people. Something similar happened at Harmony Central, a very large musicians forum with over 200,000 members. They launched a new 2.0 version of the forum that was much different in nature, and everyone bailed. They even aborted the changeover after two weeks, but it was too late. I would guess that less than half of the members who used to post there are still around. Apparently when you change a forum that people get used to, some members just leave and never return.
How else can you account for the members who have left or why this thread was even posted?
