Moderator: Andrew
brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
Higgy wrote:brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
Yeah I think its the drums that made that album suck.
brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
MCM wrote:brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
If we're going to ask for new drums can we ask him to take out all of the sax on Ambition... and everywhere else it may appear for that matter... for some reason I just hate a saxaphone in my rock n roll. I think that also dates the music.
MCM wrote:brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
If we're going to ask for new drums can we ask him to take out all of the sax on Ambition... and everywhere else it may appear for that matter... for some reason I just hate a saxaphone in my rock n roll. I think that also dates the music.
elmotano wrote:MCM wrote:brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
If we're going to ask for new drums can we ask him to take out all of the sax on Ambition... and everywhere else it may appear for that matter... for some reason I just hate a saxaphone in my rock n roll. I think that also dates the music.
Okay , but just for you. But I insist there be more cow bells, right stmonkey?
stabbim wrote:Side Note: can anyone explain to me why sounding "dated," (which apples to about 99% of recorded music) is an inherently bad thing? It's a concept that I've never fully understood.
shaka wrote:MCM wrote:brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
If we're going to ask for new drums can we ask him to take out all of the sax on Ambition... and everywhere else it may appear for that matter... for some reason I just hate a saxaphone in my rock n roll. I think that also dates the music.
That music with or without sax.......is dated.
.
brywool wrote:shaka wrote:MCM wrote:brywool wrote:Now if we can just get him to remaster and re-record all the drum tracks for What If.
Steve Holly's a great drummer, but that electronic kit sucked BIG time. Dates the album
and made it sound terrible.
Yeah, it's not his best album, but there are a few good tunes on it.
If we're going to ask for new drums can we ask him to take out all of the sax on Ambition... and everywhere else it may appear for that matter... for some reason I just hate a saxaphone in my rock n roll. I think that also dates the music.
That music with or without sax.......is dated.
.
And Styx music isn't?????
brywool wrote:shaka wrote:That music with or without sax.......is dated.
.
And Styx music isn't?????
stabbim wrote:brywool wrote:shaka wrote:That music with or without sax.......is dated.
.
And Styx music isn't?????
All popular music is. Show me a "timeless" recording, and I'll show you someone with untrained ears.
And again, I'm not really sure why this is seen as a bad thing.
<--- likes "Ambition" because of the dated sound, not in spite of it
stabbim wrote:Side Note: can anyone explain to me why sounding "dated," (which apples to about 99% of recorded music) is an inherently bad thing? It's a concept that I've never fully understood.
cinj wrote:Can you honestly say "Mr. Roboto" isn't dated? Again, to your point, a lot of people love the song....but you can't argue that there are a ton of folks who <I>hate</I> it for that very reason.
Cinj
cinj wrote:I can't really <I>explain</I> it, but some music just seems to <I>age</I> better then other music. Even in spite of the times. A great example to me is Rush's <I>Grace Under Pressure</I> - lots of synths and electronics, but it still,....you know...., <I>sounds</I> pretty good.
cinj wrote:Can you honestly say "Mr. Roboto" isn't dated? Again, to your point, a lot of people love the song....but you can't argue that there are a ton of folks who <I>hate</I> it for that very reason.
stmonkeys wrote:But there are plenty of bands out there that are timeless. Show me a "dated" led zep song.
And that probably is what separates timelessness from sounding dated. Unpredictability, versatility, innovation, production.
elmotano wrote:stabbim wrote:stmonkeys wrote:But there are plenty of bands out there that are timeless. Show me a "dated" led zep song.
Okay, all of them are dated, and I love Led Zep.
stabbim wrote:stmonkeys wrote:But there are plenty of bands out there that are timeless. Show me a "dated" led zep song.
"The Rain Song." I can spot a Mellotron at 1000 paces.![]()
And that probably is what separates timelessness from sounding dated. Unpredictability, versatility, innovation, production.
Interesting way of defining the terms. I'll have to think about that.
cinj wrote:I do like 80's music, it's just not where I would classify "classic" Styx. Just me of course.
Cinj
cinj wrote:(now, the clothes they wore, that's a different story....)
Zan wrote:elmotano wrote:stabbim wrote:stmonkeys wrote:But there are plenty of bands out there that are timeless. Show me a "dated" led zep song.
Okay, all of them are dated, and I love Led Zep.
I agree, and I DON'T love Led Zep. Ugh <--- 90% of their stuff
Sorry, Stac...but that wasn't a very good example.
stmonkeys wrote:Zan wrote:elmotano wrote:stabbim wrote:stmonkeys wrote:But there are plenty of bands out there that are timeless. Show me a "dated" led zep song.
Okay, all of them are dated, and I love Led Zep.
I agree, and I DON'T love Led Zep. Ugh <--- 90% of their stuff
Sorry, Stac...but that wasn't a very good example.
ok- here's what i mean by sounding "dated" vs not. there is a station in NYC that plays a lot of harder edge rock. WKRK aka KROCK (former home of howard stern). Most of the music they play is fairly current. You'll hear a lot of bands like Metallica, Nirvana, Limp Bizkit, Smashing Pumpkins, Foo Fighters, Chili Peppers, White Stripes, etc on that station. They will throw in some more mainstream artists as well (i've occasionally heard tom petty, u2 etc), but they play Zep, and it fits the format. It doesn't sound like they are tossing on an "oldie". The music doesn't sound "dated", like if they threw on a Hendrix song. (not dissing Jimi- he was a true musical genius, but to me his music sounds much more dated than Zep) Yeah, they were the blueprint of what became "heavy metal" (which i feel they aren't) and "hard rock", but to me they don't sound like the "dinosaur band" many dismiss them as. Also, an Aerosmith song like Same Old Song And Dance, Toys in the Attic, or Train Kept A Rollin' (yeah, i know- yardbirds) sounds less dated than something like Dude Looks Like A Lady, Ragdoll, or Angel (ick).
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests