Moderator: Andrew
piecesofeight wrote:Yeah..but at least Tom got someone who can f'n sing.. Unreal voice. This dude has a set of pipes. My favorite all time singer next to Dennis. One of my fav groups too.
Damn..Michael singing some of my fav all time songs. SWEET! No pun intended.
If you only know Michael from the old Stryper days then keep the remarks to what you know. The dude can sing/rock and the glam/bumble days are gone. Have been for years.
LtVanish wrote:I see one of Boston's tour dates also has Styx on the Bill. I wonder if there will be more.
froy wrote:LtVanish wrote:I see one of Boston's tour dates also has Styx on the Bill. I wonder if there will be more.
I sure hope not
I really would like to see Boston..
styxfanNH wrote:At the tribute to Brad, Michael was awesome. A good choice for a replacement. He can never fill Brad's shoes, but he is a very capable and suitable replacement. It will be a good show.
Blue Falcon wrote:styxfanNH wrote:At the tribute to Brad, Michael was awesome. A good choice for a replacement. He can never fill Brad's shoes, but he is a very capable and suitable replacement. It will be a good show.
This is kinda off-topic, but I think Queen made a mistake when they 'reformed' by using Paul Rodgers as the vocalist. He simply didn't have the range that ol' Freddie had. Queen should have tried to get that guy from The Darkness to sing in Freddie's place...if anyone has ever heard that band, you would agree!
Blue Falcon wrote:styxfanNH wrote:At the tribute to Brad, Michael was awesome. A good choice for a replacement. He can never fill Brad's shoes, but he is a very capable and suitable replacement. It will be a good show.
This is kinda off-topic, but I think Queen made a mistake when they 'reformed' by using Paul Rodgers as the vocalist. He simply didn't have the range that ol' Freddie had. Queen should have tried to get that guy from The Darkness to sing in Freddie's place...if anyone has ever heard that band, you would agree!
froy wrote:Blue Falcon wrote:styxfanNH wrote:At the tribute to Brad, Michael was awesome. A good choice for a replacement. He can never fill Brad's shoes, but he is a very capable and suitable replacement. It will be a good show.
This is kinda off-topic, but I think Queen made a mistake when they 'reformed' by using Paul Rodgers as the vocalist. He simply didn't have the range that ol' Freddie had. Queen should have tried to get that guy from The Darkness to sing in Freddie's place...if anyone has ever heard that band, you would agree!
I think Queeen used Paul so he did not sound like Freddie
I saw that show it was killer
elmotano wrote:froy wrote:Blue Falcon wrote:styxfanNH wrote:At the tribute to Brad, Michael was awesome. A good choice for a replacement. He can never fill Brad's shoes, but he is a very capable and suitable replacement. It will be a good show.
This is kinda off-topic, but I think Queen made a mistake when they 'reformed' by using Paul Rodgers as the vocalist. He simply didn't have the range that ol' Freddie had. Queen should have tried to get that guy from The Darkness to sing in Freddie's place...if anyone has ever heard that band, you would agree!
I think Queeen used Paul so he did not sound like Freddie
I saw that show it was killer
Wow just like Styx took Lawrence so that he doesn't sound like Dennis.
froy wrote:elmotano wrote:froy wrote:Blue Falcon wrote:styxfanNH wrote:At the tribute to Brad, Michael was awesome. A good choice for a replacement. He can never fill Brad's shoes, but he is a very capable and suitable replacement. It will be a good show.
This is kinda off-topic, but I think Queen made a mistake when they 'reformed' by using Paul Rodgers as the vocalist. He simply didn't have the range that ol' Freddie had. Queen should have tried to get that guy from The Darkness to sing in Freddie's place...if anyone has ever heard that band, you would agree!
I think Queeen used Paul so he did not sound like Freddie
I saw that show it was killer
Wow just like Styx took Lawrence so that he doesn't sound like Dennis.
No he sounds like Alvin
And he has made a fool out of himself,
The name STYX was ruined by Larry Gowan..
Killer
Wow just like Styx took Lawrence so that he doesn't sound like Dennis.
piecesofeight wrote:Again I ask..for those who support Lawrence..do you really, really think the guy can really sing? Can he really carry a tune?
piecesofeight wrote:I've made a lot of jokes about Lawrence because I really don't like him as a singer. I don't even like his solo stuff. I wuoldn't even like him if he never was a part of this whole bit we call Styx.
While to many it's a matter of opinion about why Dennis is not in Styx anymore..in all seriousness..I honestly just have never understood why it was Lawrence who was brought in. OK..fine..the guy can play keys, can twirl, jump and is a super nice guy. Fine..they for sure found someone who doesn't sound like Dennis..but with how great Dennis' voice is..I would think they would have at least found someone with a better singing voice.
For those who really support Lawrence..do you really, really think the dude can SING?
It never really hit me that the groups/artist that I continue to support are the one's who had people who could really sing. A lot of the one's I don't support anymore..have somewhat lost it.
My first time hearing Lawrence live was at the Rock To The Rescue show. Because I went there to support other artist..I told myself that even though I wasn't happy how the whole Dennis/Styx thing went down..I would be open minded.
Certain parts of the show..Tommy would come out with his guitar and do certain songs. Some people would come and join him. Jack came out to do High Enough. At one point Lawrence came out and joined. All I could do was cringe..it really was bad.
The person who came with me hadn't heard Lawrence before..but had heard Dennis' Styx songs. When Styx came out and Lawrence did Dennis' Styx songs..the person who was with me looked like they were about to either laugh or vomit.
Putting all jokes aside and what REALLY happened that I will believe from the source..Lawrence really cannot sing that well and just doesn't sing Dennis' songs well. I have heard regular joes SING Dennis' Styx songs better. Not saying they have to SOUND like Dennis..but at least carry a tune.
What to I judge being able to sing or still sing on? People like RIP-Brad Delp, DDY, Michael Sweet, Ann Wilson, Tommy Shaw-best sitting on a stool with a accoustic guitar when feeling well, Steve Perry and Jimi Jamison-of yesteryears. Those are just some. So..as I mention some in their prime..let me ask this so to prove I can cut him a break.
Has Lawrence always sounded like this? What gets me is some are saying he sounds better than ever.
Sometimes when we have someone taking the place of a lead singer who really had it..we cut them a break because we wonder how would the original person sound if they came back. Well in the Dennis/Lawrence case..we know because we hear Dennis singing the classic Styx tunes all the time. With Steve Perry..we just don't know. Brad Delp still sounded fantastic..as does Michael Sweet and Ann Wilson.
With all these groups getting back together..practically everybody..lol..we are getting a true taste of who still has it and who lost it..and reminded who never really had it..damn..there are so many who have been the lead singer who just cannot sing. I mean really SING. Carry a tune.
Not just because I am a huge fan of Boston and Stryper..but this whole thing is really just brilliant and I am completely geeked over it. If there was ever a time to use the word UNREAL..now is the time. Still pinching myself.
Again I ask..for those who support Lawrence..do you really, really think the guy can really sing? Can he really carry a tune?
I hold my own opinion on what happened with Styx/Dennis so keep that in mind as I say this so this doesn't turn into another who did what to who..even if Dennis had been out on his own terms and he was ok with everything..I still wouldn't like Lawrence singing and think he was a good choice as far as the singing of Dennis' songs. Fine..he's a great guy and can play the keys..but that's not enough when we are talking about needed someone to cover the Dennis' classic Styx songs.
Toph wrote:piecesofeight wrote:I've made a lot of jokes about Lawrence because I really don't like him as a singer. I don't even like his solo stuff. I wuoldn't even like him if he never was a part of this whole bit we call Styx.
While to many it's a matter of opinion about why Dennis is not in Styx anymore..in all seriousness..I honestly just have never understood why it was Lawrence who was brought in. OK..fine..the guy can play keys, can twirl, jump and is a super nice guy. Fine..they for sure found someone who doesn't sound like Dennis..but with how great Dennis' voice is..I would think they would have at least found someone with a better singing voice.
For those who really support Lawrence..do you really, really think the dude can SING?
It never really hit me that the groups/artist that I continue to support are the one's who had people who could really sing. A lot of the one's I don't support anymore..have somewhat lost it.
My first time hearing Lawrence live was at the Rock To The Rescue show. Because I went there to support other artist..I told myself that even though I wasn't happy how the whole Dennis/Styx thing went down..I would be open minded.
Certain parts of the show..Tommy would come out with his guitar and do certain songs. Some people would come and join him. Jack came out to do High Enough. At one point Lawrence came out and joined. All I could do was cringe..it really was bad.
The person who came with me hadn't heard Lawrence before..but had heard Dennis' Styx songs. When Styx came out and Lawrence did Dennis' Styx songs..the person who was with me looked like they were about to either laugh or vomit.
Putting all jokes aside and what REALLY happened that I will believe from the source..Lawrence really cannot sing that well and just doesn't sing Dennis' songs well. I have heard regular joes SING Dennis' Styx songs better. Not saying they have to SOUND like Dennis..but at least carry a tune.
What to I judge being able to sing or still sing on? People like RIP-Brad Delp, DDY, Michael Sweet, Ann Wilson, Tommy Shaw-best sitting on a stool with a accoustic guitar when feeling well, Steve Perry and Jimi Jamison-of yesteryears. Those are just some. So..as I mention some in their prime..let me ask this so to prove I can cut him a break.
Has Lawrence always sounded like this? What gets me is some are saying he sounds better than ever.
Sometimes when we have someone taking the place of a lead singer who really had it..we cut them a break because we wonder how would the original person sound if they came back. Well in the Dennis/Lawrence case..we know because we hear Dennis singing the classic Styx tunes all the time. With Steve Perry..we just don't know. Brad Delp still sounded fantastic..as does Michael Sweet and Ann Wilson.
With all these groups getting back together..practically everybody..lol..we are getting a true taste of who still has it and who lost it..and reminded who never really had it..damn..there are so many who have been the lead singer who just cannot sing. I mean really SING. Carry a tune.
Not just because I am a huge fan of Boston and Stryper..but this whole thing is really just brilliant and I am completely geeked over it. If there was ever a time to use the word UNREAL..now is the time. Still pinching myself.
Again I ask..for those who support Lawrence..do you really, really think the guy can really sing? Can he really carry a tune?
I hold my own opinion on what happened with Styx/Dennis so keep that in mind as I say this so this doesn't turn into another who did what to who..even if Dennis had been out on his own terms and he was ok with everything..I still wouldn't like Lawrence singing and think he was a good choice as far as the singing of Dennis' songs. Fine..he's a great guy and can play the keys..but that's not enough when we are talking about needed someone to cover the Dennis' classic Styx songs.
Max Bacon, the guy from GTR, would have made a much better Dennis sound alike..but can he play the keys?
StyxCollector wrote:
Larry by all accounts is also a nice guy and a good bandmate. So I'm not sure why there's the constant bitching and moaning other than a blind hatred for all things Styx without DDY, but we're 10 years in. Get over it.
StyxCollector wrote: blind hatred for all things Styx without DDY.
elmotano wrote:froy wrote:I think Queeen used Paul so he did not sound like Freddie
Wow just like Styx took Lawrence so that he doesn't sound like Dennis.
piecesofeight wrote:StyxCollector wrote:
Larry by all accounts is also a nice guy and a good bandmate. So I'm not sure why there's the constant bitching and moaning other than a blind hatred for all things Styx without DDY, but we're 10 years in. Get over it.
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Well good Lord..so much for what I thought was one of the nicest attempts to sincerely and seriously ask about Larry without bashing him as a human being.
Blue Falcon wrote:And for God's sake, Larry, will you PLEASE stop with the spinning keyboards??? That stupid stunt was played out by 2001.
piecesofeight wrote:![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Well good Lord..so much for what I thought was one of the nicest attempts to sincerely and seriously ask about Larry without bashing him as a human being.
piecesofeight wrote:StyxCollector wrote:
Larry by all accounts is also a nice guy and a good bandmate. So I'm not sure why there's the constant bitching and moaning other than a blind hatred for all things Styx without DDY, but we're 10 years in. Get over it.
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Well good Lord..so much for what I thought was one of the nicest attempts to sincerely and seriously ask about Larry without bashing him as a human being.
If you reread my post..I was not trying to be a jack ass. Whenever new singers are brought into any group..I believe this duscussion will continue to come up. If you also reread my post..I stated that it had nothing to do with him being a nice guy or not and I DID NOT want it turned into a bitch fest. You're the one who chose to bring that up again. All I wanted was for people to answer seriously about Larry's singing. That was it.
Good thing I don't tell people what Deano does..and that's all I am going to say because telling me to GET OVER IT is one of the things I really hate being told.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests