Tanirocker wrote:hoagiepete wrote:I don't pay them to give me a political speech. I pay them to be entertained. Bands, artists, actors, etc can say or think want they want, I just appreciate if they don't do it on my dime. In other words, if I buy a ticket for concert, I would hope to hear and see a performance, not to be preached at. Styx may be a little green. That is fine. Never heard them utter one liberal comment during a show though. If they promoted an agenda during a show, I'm done. Period.
Did you miss Tommy's speech before Man in The Wilderness?
As for being "a little green," I can say with certainty that they're all staunch Democrats.
It bothers the heck out of me when these artists make millions off us poor saps and then use the money to create a bully pulpit to pontificate on things of which they have no clue. They live in a fantasy world. It's not real and they can't figure that out.
I'm sorry, but that's absurd. I can understand saying that someone like Michael Jackson lives in a fantasy world, but working musicians live in the same world that you and I inhabit. Do you think Hollywood is on Mars? The fact that someone is in show business doesn't make them any more or less qualified to discuss issues. I'm so sick of hearing people who give their OWN opinions quite freely claiming that people in this business should just shut up. Musicians...please just give me music. If not, they should put a warning on the website when you purchase tickets that part of the show include a political message. Thankfully Styx, Journey, REO Speedwagon, KISS, Cheap Trick, Ted Nugent...just seeing if you were paying attention...etc, keep the politics off the stage. Fortunately, when I dropped a couple hundred on the Eagles a couple of years ago, they kept their lips buttoned. The ones that don't can't figure it out that they'll alienate half their fanbase, since that is about the split.
I find it disturbing when anyone attempts to put restrictions on free speech. Telling an artist, "Don't make any comments on stage that might suggest a political stance" makes my blood run cold. Some artists write political songs. Should they be careful not to verbalize their views unless they're set to music? Should they refrain (pun sort of intended) from playing political songs? What about letting groups like Move On have booths at the show? Do they have to stop allowing that?
It's not hard to find out if a particular act makes political statements. If I don't want to hear what they have to say, I don't buy tickets. If you believe in a free market, let it work. I don't agree with much that Ted Nugent says, but I think he has a right to say whatever he pleases in his shows.
Since I can't figure all the quote stuff like most of you... let me try to reply below...
First, I must of missed the Man in the Wilderness statement. I do recall...him saying it was about (his brother??) going off to war? I could have been drunk at the time...but I thought it was a statement as to what the song was about...it did not sound like preaching to me. Hence no offense taken by me...the ticket buying consumer.
Second, I don't mind the fact anyone is Democrat, Republican, Reform, whatever. Some of my best friends are Democrats. Seriously. I just don't pay them to preach to me. That's all.
Third, no offense, but many may argue that Hollywood is beyond Mars as far as being in touch with the rest of the country. It didn't get the name La La Land for nothing. Not trying to demean as there are surely many great folks out there. I can give my opinions, it pretty much don't mean shit. Give me a stage...and it suddenly means shit...even if I don't know shit.
By the way...I do not mean to paint with a broad brush...as I am sure there are many working musicians that are well read, articulate and do understand the issues (again, Ted Nugent for example...just kidding). I just think the Hollywood type were better protecting animals that trying to save the world. If it were possible to articulate the issues with valid points...without nastiness, name calling and utter hatred...then I may change my view.
Just my opinion. You'd have a hard time convincing me that many out there in the "business" have a clue about having to work 60 hours a week (all year long...not just during a movie production...recording of an album...etc), taking off work to run kids to doctor's appointments, missing work when kids are sick, going to ball games, paying bills, serving on civic and church boards and then dishing out a chunk of change to be "entertained!!"
I think the free market system will work this all out. Many were offended by the Dixie Chicks rant...they didn't buy their records. I personally chose not to buy a ticket to see Springsteen when in town because I wasn't thrilled about being preached to. It probably was more of a loss for me than him, since he still sold the tickets in this case. Thing is, I liked his stuff until he took his message outside his art. At least his message in song had a musical component that I happened to like.
I would not want to suggest restricting free speech. I think you are missing the "free" part of my point. Give it to me for free...I have no complaint. Just don't charge me to hear it. If concerts become trade shows for various movements...I'm done. Why would an artist want to divide their fan base? Seems pretty much ...ah... like a less than a sound economical approach...by doing such. Maybe they have soo frickin much money it don't matter.
I agree with you on Ted... and the others. No problem here...as long as people know what they are paying for when they buy a ticket...that's my point. I knew what I'd be in for at a Boss show, so I chose not to go. If Styx, Journey, REO or any of my other favs would suddenly unload on me with a political speech in the middle of a concert...I'd be pissed and probably lose interest in them. Tom Shultz's views are somewhat extreme...but it don't bother me...cause he ain't preachin'! He probably put in a little plug about PETA, but small enough most could roll their eyes and continue with the concert. I still like his music with Boston. Crusade if he wants...once it becomes offensive...the market will react.
In order to avoid any cold (or bad) blood...how about just giving a bunch of free concerts then???? I'd go for that.
I'm sorry this got so long... I gotta get back to work.
