Moderator: Andrew
stmonkeys wrote:oh the irony!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
dennis will bring a "DISNEY"* show to broadway.... avenging hunchback????? LOL! bravo! good luck dennis- mazel tov!
OK- technically MSG is between 7th and 8th... but close enough.
*yes i realize that this isn't the disney version...but still! LMAO
yogi wrote:Can anyone download this for me on here, I am filtered out of this website.
Thanks in advance.
brywool wrote:While this is cool for Dennis, it really does prove that Styx did the right thing by moving on without him. Sorry, but it really does. The guy is not a "rock guy" any longer and has made the leap (or fall, depending on your perspective) into musical theatre. As somone else said, that's where his heart lies and more power to him for going after what he wants to do. The same is to be said of Styx for doing what they want to do.
Geez, everybody's happy, cool.
It is really interesting that there's not been word one about it. Maybe he's just backing it? Haven't had time to read the flier.
Rockwriter wrote:This appears, at least at first glance, to be legitimate, but we shall see. Dennis is in Germany right now, I think, so maybe if this is a brand new announcement, he's not had the time to get it onto his web site. This appears to be one of only a handful of references online to this , so it may be something that's not even been the subject of a formal press release yet. It could be something where Dennis was tapped at the last minute to join an existing project, and could have something to do with Hunchback having won the Jefferson Award recently, thereby giving him more legitimacy in the eyes of theater producers. Who knows? Even though I doubt this will be my cup of tea, good for him if it comes off. Maybe it will lead to him being able to score a Disney film somewhere down the line, something I am convinced he could do very well at.
As an aside, I still don't think this makes him "not a rock guy". Do differing styles, and the ability to perform each in turn, mutually exclude one another? Not to mention the fact that he likely did not originate or conceive this project, but is once again probably just taking a job someone offered. I've never, ever understood anyone's problem with him doing different things (when Tommy does primarily acoustic-based things outside of Styx, does that make him, too, "not a rock guy"? Or Todd when he plays at jazz festivals? Or Gowan when he performed a solo concert with an orchestra?), but oh well. To each his own point of view, lol. I still see it that the best of what Styx had to offer in its prime contained a healthy dose of Dennis' melodic and dramatic flair . . . which could be construed to say that Styx in its prime was "not really a rock band", LOL. There's even plenty of critics that would agree with that statement.
cinj wrote:Good point. I think what Brywool meant was that Rock music isn't really where Dennis' heart is. Yes he can rock very well, but it seems he'd rather do musicals.
Rockwriter wrote:brywool wrote:While this is cool for Dennis, it really does prove that Styx did the right thing by moving on without him. Sorry, but it really does. The guy is not a "rock guy" any longer and has made the leap (or fall, depending on your perspective) into musical theatre. As somone else said, that's where his heart lies and more power to him for going after what he wants to do. The same is to be said of Styx for doing what they want to do.
Geez, everybody's happy, cool.
It is really interesting that there's not been word one about it. Maybe he's just backing it? Haven't had time to read the flier.
This appears, at least at first glance, to be legitimate, but we shall see. Dennis is in Germany right now, I think, so maybe if this is a brand new announcement, he's not had the time to get it onto his web site. This appears to be one of only a handful of references online to this , so it may be something that's not even been the subject of a formal press release yet. It could be something where Dennis was tapped at the last minute to join an existing project, and could have something to do with Hunchback having won the Jefferson Award recently, thereby giving him more legitimacy in the eyes of theater producers. Who knows? Even though I doubt this will be my cup of tea, good for him if it comes off. Maybe it will lead to him being able to score a Disney film somewhere down the line, something I am convinced he could do very well at.
As an aside, I still don't think this makes him "not a rock guy". Do differing styles, and the ability to perform each in turn, mutually exclude one another? Not to mention the fact that he likely did not originate or conceive this project, but is once again probably just taking a job someone offered. I've never, ever understood anyone's problem with him doing different things (when Tommy does primarily acoustic-based things outside of Styx, does that make him, too, "not a rock guy"? Or Todd when he plays at jazz festivals? Or Gowan when he performed a solo concert with an orchestra?), but oh well. To each his own point of view, lol. I still see it that the best of what Styx had to offer in its prime contained a healthy dose of Dennis' melodic and dramatic flair . . . which could be construed to say that Styx in its prime was "not really a rock band", LOL. There's even plenty of critics that would agree with that statement.
I hope all is well.
Sterling
PS What about Freddie Mercury? Pete Townshend? Elvis Presley? Are any of those guys "rock guys" by definition? Hmmm . . .
cinj wrote:[quote="Rockwriter
As an aside, I still don't think this makes him "not a rock guy". Do differing styles, and the ability to perform each in turn, mutually exclude one another? Not to mention the fact that he likely did not originate or conceive this project, but is once again probably just taking a job someone offered. I've never, ever understood anyone's problem with him doing different things (when Tommy does primarily acoustic-based things outside of Styx, does that make him, too, "not a rock guy"? Or Todd when he plays at jazz festivals? Or Gowan when he performed a solo concert with an orchestra?), but oh well. To each his own point of view, lol. I still see it that the best of what Styx had to offer in its prime contained a healthy dose of Dennis' melodic and dramatic flair . . . which could be construed to say that Styx in its prime was "not really a rock band", LOL. There's even plenty of critics that would agree with that statement.
I hope all is well.
Sterling
PS What about Freddie Mercury? Pete Townshend? Elvis Presley? Are any of those guys "rock guys" by definition? Hmmm . . .
StyxCollector wrote:cinj wrote:Good point. I think what Brywool meant was that Rock music isn't really where Dennis' heart is. Yes he can rock very well, but it seems he'd rather do musicals.
Go where the money and the opportunities are. I don't think it's too much more complicated than that. Yes, Dennis does like things other than doing the rock show (no secret there), and he wouldn't do it if he didn't want to, but I think the haters are thinking too much. You don't think that Styx wouldn't jump at the chance if someone wanted to do a musical with Styx songs in part or in whole? Oh yeah, they endorse one - Rock of Ages which they also promote on StyxWorld.com (Styx isn't the only music, but I think one or two songs are in there). Here's the banner:
So if people are going to chide Dennis, cast an equal light elsewhere. You can't have your cake and eat it, too.
brywool wrote:Rockwriter wrote:brywool wrote:While this is cool for Dennis, it really does prove that Styx did the right thing by moving on without him. Sorry, but it really does. The guy is not a "rock guy" any longer and has made the leap (or fall, depending on your perspective) into musical theatre. As somone else said, that's where his heart lies and more power to him for going after what he wants to do. The same is to be said of Styx for doing what they want to do.
Geez, everybody's happy, cool.
It is really interesting that there's not been word one about it. Maybe he's just backing it? Haven't had time to read the flier.
This appears, at least at first glance, to be legitimate, but we shall see. Dennis is in Germany right now, I think, so maybe if this is a brand new announcement, he's not had the time to get it onto his web site. This appears to be one of only a handful of references online to this , so it may be something that's not even been the subject of a formal press release yet. It could be something where Dennis was tapped at the last minute to join an existing project, and could have something to do with Hunchback having won the Jefferson Award recently, thereby giving him more legitimacy in the eyes of theater producers. Who knows? Even though I doubt this will be my cup of tea, good for him if it comes off. Maybe it will lead to him being able to score a Disney film somewhere down the line, something I am convinced he could do very well at.
As an aside, I still don't think this makes him "not a rock guy". Do differing styles, and the ability to perform each in turn, mutually exclude one another? Not to mention the fact that he likely did not originate or conceive this project, but is once again probably just taking a job someone offered. I've never, ever understood anyone's problem with him doing different things (when Tommy does primarily acoustic-based things outside of Styx, does that make him, too, "not a rock guy"? Or Todd when he plays at jazz festivals? Or Gowan when he performed a solo concert with an orchestra?), but oh well. To each his own point of view, lol. I still see it that the best of what Styx had to offer in its prime contained a healthy dose of Dennis' melodic and dramatic flair . . . which could be construed to say that Styx in its prime was "not really a rock band", LOL. There's even plenty of critics that would agree with that statement.
I hope all is well.
Sterling
PS What about Freddie Mercury? Pete Townshend? Elvis Presley? Are any of those guys "rock guys" by definition? Hmmm . . .
Then let's phrase it like this:
The guy obviously didn't have time for Styx, so the band made the right decision and Dennis is getting full control over everything he does. Everybody wins except Froy.
StyxCollector wrote:Put another way: notice the incessant touring is kinda over. The dead horse has seen its last beating. I think at this point Styx is trying to figure out the plan going forward. New material? Tricky - it's not going to sell that well; they'd be better of just selling stuff at shows at $20 a pop. They'd make more money if they did it themselves. Little reward for lots of effort. Touring? Well, again, that ship has left to some degree, too. Look at their touring schedule - a cluster of dates in a concentrated area (for example, 2/6 - 2/21 on the West Coast). JY's wife's illness certainly factors in as well. Bottom line: they can't do what they've been doing. They need a new game plan. I don't think they even know what it is at this point.
Dennis has certainly done what he wanted and managed things totally different. He's not playing any larger venues or different rib fests (lol) than Styx is, but playing live isn't his primary focus. I'm sure he's getting paid well to do the dates in Europe right now.
I'm not sure what Dennis coming back would buy either side at this point.
Toph wrote:I don't think you will ever see it happen - unless the current band tooks 2-3 years off. But then the core fans are getting that much older - some are bordering on grandparents status...
Rockwriter wrote:brywool wrote:Rockwriter wrote:brywool wrote:While this is cool for Dennis, it really does prove that Styx did the right thing by moving on without him. Sorry, but it really does. The guy is not a "rock guy" any longer and has made the leap (or fall, depending on your perspective) into musical theatre. As somone else said, that's where his heart lies and more power to him for going after what he wants to do. The same is to be said of Styx for doing what they want to do.
Geez, everybody's happy, cool.
It is really interesting that there's not been word one about it. Maybe he's just backing it? Haven't had time to read the flier.
This appears, at least at first glance, to be legitimate, but we shall see. Dennis is in Germany right now, I think, so maybe if this is a brand new announcement, he's not had the time to get it onto his web site. This appears to be one of only a handful of references online to this , so it may be something that's not even been the subject of a formal press release yet. It could be something where Dennis was tapped at the last minute to join an existing project, and could have something to do with Hunchback having won the Jefferson Award recently, thereby giving him more legitimacy in the eyes of theater producers. Who knows? Even though I doubt this will be my cup of tea, good for him if it comes off. Maybe it will lead to him being able to score a Disney film somewhere down the line, something I am convinced he could do very well at.
As an aside, I still don't think this makes him "not a rock guy". Do differing styles, and the ability to perform each in turn, mutually exclude one another? Not to mention the fact that he likely did not originate or conceive this project, but is once again probably just taking a job someone offered. I've never, ever understood anyone's problem with him doing different things (when Tommy does primarily acoustic-based things outside of Styx, does that make him, too, "not a rock guy"? Or Todd when he plays at jazz festivals? Or Gowan when he performed a solo concert with an orchestra?), but oh well. To each his own point of view, lol. I still see it that the best of what Styx had to offer in its prime contained a healthy dose of Dennis' melodic and dramatic flair . . . which could be construed to say that Styx in its prime was "not really a rock band", LOL. There's even plenty of critics that would agree with that statement.
I hope all is well.
Sterling
PS What about Freddie Mercury? Pete Townshend? Elvis Presley? Are any of those guys "rock guys" by definition? Hmmm . . .
Then let's phrase it like this:
The guy obviously didn't have time for Styx, so the band made the right decision and Dennis is getting full control over everything he does. Everybody wins except Froy.
LOL, maybe so. I still believe he'll be back at some point, but who knows? The band members themselves don't really know. In the meantime it's going to continue like it has for years, with some fans supporting one, some fans supporting the other, some fans supporting both, and some choosing not to support either entity if they can't have exactly the combination of people that they want. In other words, business as usual!
Sterling
classicstyxfan wrote:62 is the age one is eligible to begin collecting social security isnt it ?
I believe 1 or 2 Styx members are perilously close to eligibility..........
If they ever do have that long hoped for reunion, I hope they can all still remember their parts and the lyrics !
tick-toc-tick-toc
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests