The_Noble_Cause wrote:Considering that Joe sits most of the choruses out and lets the BG singers do the heavy lifting, I'd say their performances are comparable. In fact, during Hold the Line, the band now needs 3 singers to do Bobby's job. As I said in an earlier thread, switching to Joe isn't an upgrade. The band is trading one old tenor for another old tenor. Sure, Joe can sing the chorus of Africa, but he needs the BG vocalists to do the very last "Bless the Rains" stanza which Bobby always went for. So the trade-off is moot. I agree. Bring 'em both back.
Good point. That said, I don't miss Bobby. I've seen him twice with Toto (2005 and 2007) and my impression was the same each time ... that he's an incredibly inconsistent live singer. I thought he'd sound spectacular on some songs and utterly dreadful on others.
Listening to the boots of this tour, Joe seems more consistent throughout, even if he doesn't quite have the same range.