Moderator: Andrew
Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Call me a prude, but I would like "Light Up" more if the lyrical content was different. Wish they had just kept it as a tribute to the Beatles. Hard to play a song glorifying marijuana use with kids in the car.
Baron Von Bielski wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
I totally agree. DDY sounds just as good now as ever.
Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Call me a prude, but I would like "Light Up" more if the lyrical content was different. Wish they had just kept it as a tribute to the Beatles. Hard to play a song glorifying marijuana use with kids in the car.
IMHO, it has to be one of the most tame songs (lyrically) about the subject of pot. In fact, I would be willing to bet that at the time most of the "kids" that heard it wouldn't figure it out for themselves. I have never heard someone say "I started smoking pot because I heard about it in a song".
Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Call me a prude, but I would like "Light Up" more if the lyrical content was different. Wish they had just kept it as a tribute to the Beatles. Hard to play a song glorifying marijuana use with kids in the car.
IMHO, it has to be one of the most tame songs (lyrically) about the subject of pot. In fact, I would be willing to bet that at the time most of the "kids" that heard it wouldn't figure it out for themselves. I have never heard someone say "I started smoking pot because I heard about it in a song".
I have to disagree with you there. Anything that makes it sound permissible is IMHO, a gateway into kids thinking it is acceptable. I just don't think it is right to be driving around with a song that glorifies and encourages pot usage (how about the end - smoke Marijuana repeated over and over and over again) with kids in the car. I'm not going to be playing Eric Clapton's "Cocaine" or Marley's songs either. Just my choice on that. Again, like the tune of Light Up (although the middle instrumental section is a bit long - could have come back with another verse), but not a big fan of the lyrical content. Also and link to another thread - Journey doesn't have any songs about glorifying drugs.
Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Call me a prude, but I would like "Light Up" more if the lyrical content was different. Wish they had just kept it as a tribute to the Beatles. Hard to play a song glorifying marijuana use with kids in the car.
IMHO, it has to be one of the most tame songs (lyrically) about the subject of pot. In fact, I would be willing to bet that at the time most of the "kids" that heard it wouldn't figure it out for themselves. I have never heard someone say "I started smoking pot because I heard about it in a song".
I have to disagree with you there. Anything that makes it sound permissible is IMHO, a gateway into kids thinking it is acceptable. I just don't think it is right to be driving around with a song that glorifies and encourages pot usage (how about the end - smoke Marijuana repeated over and over and over again) with kids in the car. I'm not going to be playing Eric Clapton's "Cocaine" or Marley's songs either. Just my choice on that. Again, like the tune of Light Up (although the middle instrumental section is a bit long - could have come back with another verse), but not a big fan of the lyrical content. Also and link to another thread - Journey doesn't have any songs about glorifying drugs.
Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Call me a prude, but I would like "Light Up" more if the lyrical content was different. Wish they had just kept it as a tribute to the Beatles. Hard to play a song glorifying marijuana use with kids in the car.
IMHO, it has to be one of the most tame songs (lyrically) about the subject of pot. In fact, I would be willing to bet that at the time most of the "kids" that heard it wouldn't figure it out for themselves. I have never heard someone say "I started smoking pot because I heard about it in a song".
I have to disagree with you there. Anything that makes it sound permissible is IMHO, a gateway into kids thinking it is acceptable. I just don't think it is right to be driving around with a song that glorifies and encourages pot usage (how about the end - smoke Marijuana repeated over and over and over again) with kids in the car. I'm not going to be playing Eric Clapton's "Cocaine" or Marley's songs either. Just my choice on that. Again, like the tune of Light Up (although the middle instrumental section is a bit long - could have come back with another verse), but not a big fan of the lyrical content. Also and link to another thread - Journey doesn't have any songs about glorifying drugs.
Toph wrote:I am glad so many of you have opinions on how I should raise my kids. Really appreciate that. And you can be sure I'll take to heart what a bunch of folks on a washed up band's internet site have to say.
I choose to not have my kids listen to songs that glorify marijuana use. Light Up fits that category. So sue me. And I've talked to them many times on the danger of drugs - I just don't think it is appropriate to play songs in the car that they may then go and sing in front of other kids, teachers, etc. that say "Light Up and get happy...smoke marijuana!". It is inappropriate. And if you have a problem with that, tough luck. I am raising my kids the way I see fit - you aren't.
Toph wrote:I am glad so many of you have opinions on how I should raise my kids. Really appreciate that. And you can be sure I'll take to heart what a bunch of folks on a washed up band's internet site have to say.
I choose to not have my kids listen to songs that glorify marijuana use. Light Up fits that category. So sue me. And I've talked to them many times on the danger of drugs - I just don't think it is appropriate to play songs in the car that they may then go and sing in front of other kids, teachers, etc. that say "Light Up and get happy...smoke marijuana!". It is inappropriate. And if you have a problem with that, tough luck. I am raising my kids the way I see fit - you aren't.
Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Toph wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I have been listening to the remastered version of 'Light Up' from Equinox/Crystal Ball and I just need to comment on what an excellent song it is. Listening to it with headphones on I was able to hear the layers of guitars especially during the verse. Sounds you can't really hear otherwise... at least not as clear or prominent. It's a great opener to an album and I think it'd a great opener to a concert. Styx was using the beginning to their shows last year before they'd kick in to Borrowed Time which I liked, but it's not the same without Dennis singing it. Plus there is no way I'd want Gowan trying 'Light Up', I'm not bashing him... but his voice doesn't work for it... at all. As much as people say he's a Dennis sound alike, I don't think so at all. Not even the same key. Anyways, it's about the song and how great is and how great Styx was... and COULD be again.
Personally, I feel it's an insult to Dennis to say that Gowan is a sound alike. Dennis' vocal abilities are far and above anything Gowan has done. Gowan is not even in the same league, period.
Call me a prude, but I would like "Light Up" more if the lyrical content was different. Wish they had just kept it as a tribute to the Beatles. Hard to play a song glorifying marijuana use with kids in the car.
IMHO, it has to be one of the most tame songs (lyrically) about the subject of pot. In fact, I would be willing to bet that at the time most of the "kids" that heard it wouldn't figure it out for themselves. I have never heard someone say "I started smoking pot because I heard about it in a song".
I have to disagree with you there. Anything that makes it sound permissible is IMHO, a gateway into kids thinking it is acceptable. I just don't think it is right to be driving around with a song that glorifies and encourages pot usage (how about the end - smoke Marijuana repeated over and over and over again) with kids in the car. I'm not going to be playing Eric Clapton's "Cocaine" or Marley's songs either. Just my choice on that. Again, like the tune of Light Up (although the middle instrumental section is a bit long - could have come back with another verse), but not a big fan of the lyrical content. Also and link to another thread - Journey doesn't have any songs about glorifying drugs.
Toph wrote:I am glad so many of you have opinions on how I should raise my kids. Really appreciate that. And you can be sure I'll take to heart what a bunch of folks on a washed up band's internet site have to say.
I choose to not have my kids listen to songs that glorify marijuana use. Light Up fits that category. So sue me. And I've talked to them many times on the danger of drugs - I just don't think it is appropriate to play songs in the car that they may then go and sing in front of other kids, teachers, etc. that say "Light Up and get happy...smoke marijuana!". It is inappropriate. And if you have a problem with that, tough luck. I am raising my kids the way I see fit - you aren't.
Higgy wrote:Toph wrote:I am glad so many of you have opinions on how I should raise my kids. Really appreciate that. And you can be sure I'll take to heart what a bunch of folks on a washed up band's internet site have to say.
I choose to not have my kids listen to songs that glorify marijuana use. Light Up fits that category. So sue me. And I've talked to them many times on the danger of drugs - I just don't think it is appropriate to play songs in the car that they may then go and sing in front of other kids, teachers, etc. that say "Light Up and get happy...smoke marijuana!". It is inappropriate. And if you have a problem with that, tough luck. I am raising my kids the way I see fit - you aren't.
Maybe you should go smoke some weed and calm down - Dennis Deyoung would.
Baron Von Bielski wrote:I started this topic to talk about the music and melody of this great song. Not really the lyrical content. If that were the case, and I overanalyzed it... I might not think as highly of it. Oh, and I can guarantee one thing... my kids aren't "singing" along with this one in the car I assure you. If it ain't their choice, then it's headphones on. Works for me, nobody likes what I like anyway.
Toph wrote:how about the end - smoke Marijuana repeated over and over and over again
kansas666 wrote:Toph wrote:how about the end - smoke Marijuana repeated over and over and over again
You've got to listen real close to hear that. Put the headphones on.
It always sounded like "smoke dope" to me.
Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I started this topic to talk about the music and melody of this great song. Not really the lyrical content. If that were the case, and I overanalyzed it... I might not think as highly of it. Oh, and I can guarantee one thing... my kids aren't "singing" along with this one in the car I assure you. If it ain't their choice, then it's headphones on. Works for me, nobody likes what I like anyway.
Amazing how a thread can veer off in another direction isn't it? I don't think you had anything to do with where this went.
Ash wrote:OMG... a 70's prog rock band singing a song about drugs.
What will be next? Them singing a song about doing ladies in waiting while stealing their gold? In a church no less.
What HAS the world come to?
On their next album they'll be talking about sex with 17 year olds.
Baron Von Bielski wrote:Boomchild wrote:Baron Von Bielski wrote:I started this topic to talk about the music and melody of this great song. Not really the lyrical content. If that were the case, and I overanalyzed it... I might not think as highly of it. Oh, and I can guarantee one thing... my kids aren't "singing" along with this one in the car I assure you. If it ain't their choice, then it's headphones on. Works for me, nobody likes what I like anyway.
Amazing how a thread can veer off in another direction isn't it? I don't think you had anything to do with where this went.
You know what's kinda embarrassing, I have never "really" listened to the words that closely. Now obviously I've listened to "Everyday's a holiday when your lips meet mine...", and so on. Kinda cheesy. Even the line "All I need is just one hit to get me by" I took is as a metephor like a hit of love because of the "when I'm with you I'm halfway high". Like being high on love. As far as "Light Up, everybody"... I never paid attention to the line. I am embarrassed to say I didn't know the song was about pot when I started this thread. I am not a naive person either, but this one sure slipped by the ol' radar.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests