Styx January 2012

[Archetype]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

[pinkfloyd1973]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

He looks pretty good for a guy going on 65

[brywool]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

Dennis looks super old to me. On stage, he looks much older than Gowan- big deal. Although his hair looks only to be a few months old. And he REALLY needs to lose the air guitar moves, they don't suit him. How any of them look has nothing to do with their talent... "genius". No need to be a jerk dude. I just don't agree with you. That's usually how it goes with these conversations though.

ALL of these guys are talented players and singers. Gowan doesn't sound like Dennis. You know what? Dennis doesn't sound like Gowan either. Nobody's voice is going to sound like someone else's. Gowan's doing a credible job covering the tunes and he's also good to the Styx fans AND from what I've seen is always respectful to Dennis and what he did for Styx. Why are Dennis' fans so disrespectful to the others? JY should learn to be a bit more classy when he talks about the past and Dennis is always classy when he talks about any of em. Get over it kids, Dennis is out of the band. If you don't like it, start a Dennis Deyoung group. I'd gladly read it. There are some here that can appreciate both camps and others that are just psycho.

[ChicagoSTYX]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

At first glance I thought that was JY and Ricky with DDY. Thought I may have missed something!

[brywool]

At first glance I thought that was JY and Ricky with DDY. Thought I may have missed something!

The dude looks a LOT like JY.

[Monker]

To me, it's like Perry's situation from Journey. The band waited and waited for him. When he was finally ready, he only half committed. So both bands moved on. Bands are businesses. What choice was left for either of these bands?

Well, correction here....They didn't wait for Perry. The entire band was already together, with the exception of Perry, and ready to record...songs were already being written. Kevin Chalfant was replacing him, and Gregg Rolie was in the band, too. Perry was touring solo for FTLOSM and basically, Sony wanted him in Journey and offered a deal to Perry and Journey to get him back. So, I don't think his heart was truly dedicated to Journey...I think he wanted to be solo.

Now, AFTER that, the band waited and waited for Perry to do the TBF reunion tour and Perry wouldn't tour because of his hip, wouldn't get surgery, and everything was delayed. The band got tired of waiting and came to a legal agreement to replace him.

One thing of interest here is that way back then Tommy wrote on his blog that he actually called and talked to Jonathan Cain for advice on replacing lead singers. He did not really elaborate on it much...just said they talked. I always thought it was to get advice on hiring a soundalike, or somebody who different, or what...especailly since they already had Gowan as a possibility. Don't know what Jonathan said to him.

[Boomchild]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

Why are Dennis' fans so disrespectful to the others? JY should learn to be a bit more classy when he talks about the past and Dennis is always classy when he talks about any of em.

Maybe it's because they were not respectful to Dennis during and after the break up. What have they done in regards to Dennis to deserve respect?

[Babyblue]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

Thanks, for sharing this. I loved it & am so ready to get my Styx fix again.

[Babyblue]

The band likes to work. That's the way it should be.
Without new music though, I just can't buy a ticket.
I've seen them a million times over the years.
The only thing that'd make me go see them is
if they were promoting an album of new music.

I don't need new music cause i am still going to see them.

[Cassie May]

One thing of interest here is that way back then Tommy wrote on his blog that he actually called and talked to Jonathan Cain for advice on replacing lead singers. He did not really elaborate on it much...just said they talked. I always thought it was to get advice on hiring a soundalike, or somebody who different, or what...especailly since they already had Gowan as a possibility. Don't know what Jonathan said to him.

I read that blog, too, and I believe Tommy added that Jonathan said to move quickly. Make a decision fast and get the new guy in as quickly as possible. I read another interview which stated that they didn't necessarily want a sound-alike. Just someone that would add energy to the band and his own spin on the songs without taking away too much from the original versions.

Not to add any muck to the fan wars, but while I personally don't care much for Gowan's voice, he does add a lot to the band. I enjoy watching him onstage more than I ever liked watching Dennis. (There were times I didn't care for Dennis' voice, either.) Dennis was so hokey and contrived, and I have never forgotten watching him singing to Miss Piggy during the PT tour and thinking, "What the hell...?" I appreciate the fact that all the guys now are much more entertaining to watch, and you can tell they are enjoying themselves, too. I saw Styx in their heyday and I have seen them as they are now (most recently, 2 GI/Po8 shows), and I really enjoy them more now. Just my opinion.

[Boomchild]

One thing of interest here is that way back then Tommy wrote on his blog that he actually called and talked to Jonathan Cain for advice on replacing lead singers. He did not really elaborate on it much...just said they talked. I always thought it was to get advice on hiring a soundalike, or somebody who different, or what...especailly since they already had Gowan as a possibility. Don't know what Jonathan said to him.

I have never forgotten watching him singing to Miss Piggy during the PT tour and thinking, "What the hell...?" .

Yeah, it's kinda like watching a "Rockin'" band like Styx playing to ice skaters.

[brywool]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

Why are Dennis' fans so disrespectful to the others? JY should learn to be a bit more classy when he talks about the past and Dennis is always classy when he talks about any of em.

Maybe it's because they were not respectful to Dennis during and after the break up. What have they done in regards to Dennis to deserve respect?

It was a breakup and not a friendly one. Had nothing to do with "the fans" (fanatics)

[Boomchild]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

Why are Dennis' fans so disrespectful to the others? JY should learn to be a bit more classy when he talks about the past and Dennis is always classy when he talks about any of em.

Maybe it's because they were not respectful to Dennis during and after the break up. What have they done in regards to Dennis to deserve respect?

It was a breakup and not a friendly one. Had nothing to do with "the fans" (fanatics)

I see, so since it was not directed at the fans then they still deserve respect regardless of their actions or ethics? If a guy is robbing my neighbors house then I should tell him to have a nice day as he rides off with his loot?

[yogi]

I should be at a Styx concert tonight in Ft. Worth. After a great show I will wait by my mail box for my Grand Illusion/Pieces Of Eight CD/DVD- Blue Ray of the concert I couldnt wait to see with or without DDY.

Instead I will be TBowing ' Behind The Music' and listening to Dream Theatre.

Gotta love that ice skating jewelry wearing coffee drinking HARD rockin band.

[Monker]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

Why are Dennis' fans so disrespectful to the others? JY should learn to be a bit more classy when he talks about the past and Dennis is always classy when he talks about any of em.

Maybe it's because they were not respectful to Dennis during and after the break up. What have they done in regards to Dennis to deserve respect?

It was a breakup and not a friendly one. Had nothing to do with "the fans" (fanatics)

I see, so since it was not directed at the fans then they still deserve respect regardless of their actions or ethics? If a guy is robbing my neighbors house then I should tell him to have a nice day as he rides off with his loot?

Yeah, you're right. DDY fans are the type of people who would go about 13yrs later to every bar in town to talk about how much you hate this guy who broke into your neighbor's house, and that you would make your life's work to express your obsession forever and ever...even though most people just don't give a damn and wish you would just shut the fuck up already and move on with your life.

[Boomchild]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

What dreck. Gowan's voice if weak, flat, inconsistently raspy, and just plain bad. He also looks old, and drunk. A sucky rendition through and through. He should be banned from singing that song.

DENNIS DOESN'T LOOK OLD?

Dennis IS like 8 1/2 years older genius.

Dennis's face looks a lot younger than Lawrence's; compare the Rosie picture of Lawrence to this:

Why are Dennis' fans so disrespectful to the others? JY should learn to be a bit more classy when he talks about the past and Dennis is always classy when he talks about any of em.

Maybe it's because they were not respectful to Dennis during and after the break up. What have they done in regards to Dennis to deserve respect?

It was a breakup and not a friendly one. Had nothing to do with "the fans" (fanatics)

I see, so since it was not directed at the fans then they still deserve respect regardless of their actions or ethics? If a guy is robbing my neighbors house then I should tell him to have a nice day as he rides off with his loot?

Yeah, you're right. DDY fans are the type of people who would go about 13yrs later to every bar in town to talk about how much you hate this guy who broke into your neighbor's house, and that you would make your life's work to express your obsession forever and ever...even though most people just don't give a damn and wish you would just shut the fuck up already and move on with your life.

I'm sorry...... Did you say something???

[Boomchild]

Here's a clip of the entire performance from Rosie's show. Was it really necessary for her to join in??

http://www.oprah.com/rosie/Styx-Perform ... Away-Video

Well, Can't wait for their appearance on "The View". Todd's got nothing on Rosie when it comes to drumming. They need to replace Todd with Rosie, add a third bass player and put more eye liner on Gowan and BINGO! JY will have his "Best Version Of Styx Ever"

BTW, the clip missed the part where the band gave each audience member Styx blend Bon Bons (Thin Rock hard shell on the outside with soft rock shell on the inside) plus, the never before seen "Oh Mamma" tie dye moo moo dress.

[Ash]

I should be at a Styx concert tonight in Ft. Worth. After a great show I will wait by my mail box for my Grand Illusion/Pieces Of Eight CD/DVD- Blue Ray of the concert I couldnt wait to see with or without DDY.

Instead I will be TBowing ' Behind The Music' and listening to Dream Theatre.

Gotta love that ice skating jewelry wearing coffee drinking HARD rockin band.

I heard a rumor about a new product line for next year.

Styx Fertilizer.... made with real JY Bullshit.

[ChicagoSTYX]

I guess the DDY faithful have nothing better to do these days but to try and diminish the fact that Styx is all over the tv this month.

[pinkfloyd1973]

I guess the DDY faithful have nothing better to do these days but to try and diminish the fact that Styx is all over the tv this month.

I guess any publicity is better than nothing

[ChicagoSTYX]

I guess the DDY faithful have nothing better to do these days but to try and diminish the fact that Styx is all over the tv this month.

I guess any publicity is better than nothing

Yes, if you can be on national tv 3 times in one week that's a good thing.
Gotta go now, picking up a pizza on my way over to Froy's house to watch Styx on ice.

[pinkfloyd1973]

I guess the DDY faithful have nothing better to do these days but to try and diminish the fact that Styx is all over the tv this month.

I guess any publicity is better than nothing

Yes, if you can be on national tv 3 times in one week that's a good thing.
Gotta go now, picking up a pizza on my way over to Froy's house to watch Styx on ice.

Suite will harass me for this.....but i'd rather watch the Packers game

[bugsymalone]

Of course, the TV stuff IS exposure, but what kind?

If we want to compare appearances. Dennis gets Jimmy Kimmel and Styx gets...cable Rosie. Dennis shares the spotlight with legendary singers on a Simon Cowell produced competition program and Styx gets...figure skating.

Just sayin........


Bugsy

[SuiteMadameBlue]

I guess the DDY faithful have nothing better to do these days but to try and diminish the fact that Styx is all over the tv this month.

I guess any publicity is better than nothing

Yes, if you can be on national tv 3 times in one week that's a good thing.
Gotta go now, picking up a pizza on my way over to Froy's house to watch Styx on ice.

Suite will harass me for this.....but i'd rather watch the Packers game

I applaud you Robin, I knew you'd see the light someday with the Packers!!! ;)

I'm worried about this game, I hope they win!!!

[ChicagoSTYX]

Of course, the TV stuff IS exposure, but what kind?

If we want to compare appearances. Dennis gets Jimmy Kimmel and Styx gets...cable Rosie. Dennis shares the spotlight with legendary singers on a Simon Cowell produced competition program and Styx gets...figure skating.

Just sayin........


Bugsy

I missed that one. What show was he on and when?

Just saw a commercial for GI/POE and CYO DVDs

[ChicagoSTYX]

Omg, I think Chuck just hit Nancy Kerrigan on the knee with his bass!

[pinkfloyd1973]

Omg, I think Chuck just hit Nancy Kerrigan on the knee with his bass!

"WHYYYYYYYY, OHWHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!"

[pinkfloyd1973]

I guess the DDY faithful have nothing better to do these days but to try and diminish the fact that Styx is all over the tv this month.

I guess any publicity is better than nothing

Yes, if you can be on national tv 3 times in one week that's a good thing.
Gotta go now, picking up a pizza on my way over to Froy's house to watch Styx on ice.

Ice Capades, seriously?

[ChicagoSTYX]

Styx on ice was better then I thought it would be. They played 10 songs and sounded great!

[ChicagoSTYX]

I guess the DDY faithful have nothing better to do these days but to try and diminish the fact that Styx is all over the tv this month.

I guess any publicity is better than nothing

Yes, if you can be on national tv 3 times in one week that's a good thing.
Gotta go now, picking up a pizza on my way over to Froy's house to watch Styx on ice.

Ice Capades, seriously?

Did you watch it?