Seven Wishes wrote:BB isn't perfect, but the guy has won 80% of his games with a legendary QB and often little else. I can think of few coaches who could have coaxed five SB appearances (and three wins) with the personnel he's had. What a sham.
I agree. To put Bellichick on that list at #2 is downright awful. Even though over the past few years his mix and match decisions with player personal in Free Agency and not being able to super-glue the "defensive mastermind" stigma the past few years (I don't think he's as big of a defensive-minded genius as people paint him out to be) he's possibly one of the greatest coach's that ever coached (Spygate excluded.)
Now it's time to defend my coach. Tomlin has shown nothing but straight up will and iron of a personality the moment he stepped into the Steelers organization. Not only did he overtake a Super Bowl team coming off a putrid 2006 season, one in which his franchise QB almost died in an accident plus a appendectomy weeks within each other, he followed one of the most BELOVED coach's in all the NFL in Bill Cowher and his untouchable resume.
Not only that, but he beat out fan-favorites Ken Whisenhunt and Russ Grimm to become Pittsburgh's first black head coach ever (when the league was still only Dungy and Lovie Smith.)
Mix in the fact that he had to deal with tremendous ego's and made the TOUGH decision to deal with the likes of a disgruntled All-Pro like Alan Faneca, but he also let big-time fan favorite Joey Porter walk. He then went onto deal with the Roethlisberger sex-scandals and didn't blind when scrutiny hit Pittsburgh in that regard and kept his players focused during one of those time periods, ultimatley leading his team to the Super Bowl in 2010 the same year Ben put shame on Pittsburgh.
The offensive line has literally been a revolving door's version of musical chairs during his whole entire tenure as Steelers coach and has been the worst unit in all of football the past few years. That and he won the Super Bowl in '08 with seemingly one of the hardest schedules in NFL history. Yeah, I don't think Tomlin is in the LEAST bit overrated (even though he's been iffy in some spots this season in some bad management and decisions at times.)
He became the 4th fastest coach to 60 regular season wins since 1970. Tomlin did it in 88 games, only beaten by Seifert, Gibbs and Ditka. That's not over-ration.