
thankfully he is alive and kicking!

Moderator: Andrew
Tomulator wrote:A few points...
1) I'll post whatever and wherever I feel like it. Deal with it.
Tomulator wrote:2) NS has intimated that he's open to a broader scope with this JTT lineup...that is where my idea came from. It is relevant, appropriate to bring up, and makes total sense. No wonder it doesn't resonate with you...
Tomulator wrote:3) Do you have a job or something else you're supposed to do all day? You seem to be constantly on these pages, acting like some "authority" (which you clearly are NOT), and frequently attacking other posters trying to minimize their input. Kind of creepy...
scarab wrote:actually TNC bailed so long from here some thought he was dead....![]()
thankfully he is alive and kicking!
scarab wrote:I just can't wait to hear/see Rolie/Schon play the "old stuff". And deen singing them? wow.
I would love to hear Next, with Deen and Rolie trade off vocals.
And Deen doing Sweet and Simple...
Die hard fans...Wont even give a damn that they dont do DSB. I sure wouldn't.
I should have bought tickets, but as they are playing a 1000 or less seater, that was impossible, I think they sold out in minutes.
I just hope all the songs get uploaded to youtube.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Tomulator wrote:A few points...
1) I'll post whatever and wherever I feel like it. Deal with it.
You posted an off-the-wall and frankly, ridiculous idea and I gave my opinion. Perry is not coming back. To bring this up in every Journey-related topic is beyond comical at this point. Especially when there is actual REAL news of founding member Rolie being back.Tomulator wrote:2) NS has intimated that he's open to a broader scope with this JTT lineup...that is where my idea came from. It is relevant, appropriate to bring up, and makes total sense. No wonder it doesn't resonate with you...
You said you want a SP band that would perform "ENTIRELY new material." JTT is about playing OLDER songs that Cain/Valory won't allow NS to play. You are just shoe-horning SP worship into a thread where it doesn't belong.Tomulator wrote:3) Do you have a job or something else you're supposed to do all day? You seem to be constantly on these pages, acting like some "authority" (which you clearly are NOT), and frequently attacking other posters trying to minimize their input. Kind of creepy...
Nah, I’m on disability. Hurt my hip while hiking in Hawaii.
Tomulator wrote:I bet you can't sing.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Tomulator wrote:I bet you can't sing.
Wrong.
Tomulator wrote:
Right.
Tomulator wrote:Fair enough.
For the record, I am not against this JTT lineup/show. I just had a different, offshoot idea...that was all.
Lora wrote:I'm going and I'm really looking forward to it. Last time they dangled the "Neal & Gregg together again" carrot in front of me was at Journey's last show at AT&T Park. Did I see Gregg? Nope. Was I pissed? Still am.![]()
Gregg better be at this gig.
tater1977 wrote:Lora wrote:I'm going and I'm really looking forward to it. Last time they dangled the "Neal & Gregg together again" carrot in front of me was at Journey's last show at AT&T Park. Did I see Gregg? Nope. Was I pissed? Still am.![]()
Gregg better be at this gig.
Grab a sound byte or two for us droolers.
Most importantly have fun and enjoy.
If Rolie is a no-show, throw a chair at Schon for us.![]()
The_Noble_Cause wrote:tater1977 wrote:Lora wrote:I'm going and I'm really looking forward to it. Last time they dangled the "Neal & Gregg together again" carrot in front of me was at Journey's last show at AT&T Park. Did I see Gregg? Nope. Was I pissed? Still am.![]()
Gregg better be at this gig.
Grab a sound byte or two for us droolers.
Most importantly have fun and enjoy.
If Rolie is a no-show, throw a chair at Schon for us.![]()
Deen's tech tweeted a photo of Rolie rehearsing with the guys, so I think your good.
Tomulator wrote:To me, this is a golden opportunity for NS to "piggyback" off of Journey with a new lineup...I suggest the following.
- NS, Rollie, Smitty, and either Randy Jackson or Ross should pitch a new band idea to SP. This band would be the next "phase" of Journey...too bad "Arrival" as a band name is already been taken...the band would have a new name/identity.
- The idea behind this new band would be to write and perform ENTIRELY new material...written explicitly around SP's vocal abilities...as they are TODAY. There would be allowed NO falling back to old Journey material...this band would operate as it's own entity, almost like a sequal to a movie. An entirely new thing.
- Touring could likewise be tailored to the desires/abilities of the collective members...tour material would be EXCLUSIVELY the newly penned material...NO "dirty dozen" to be played...and be up front about it!
I think, if pitched to Perry in this way, he may bite on it. Think about it, it solves what I believe is (and has been) the main reason SP left the stage...diminished vocal range. New material would allow that issue to be addressed.
Finally, I believe that a NS/SP colloboration (i.e., a "new" Journey for a new age) would still carry enough weight to be successful. The vast majority of Journey fans want to see a lineup with SP again...this idea would allow that to happen and for SP to "save face" given his reduced vocal abilities these days.
A man can dream can't he?
bellairepark73 wrote:Art Vandelay wrote:What Neal is forgetting is that the Dead and Phish fans would attend their shows fully expecting a 4+ hour jam session. That's not what the average ticket buying Journey fan is out for these days, especially if the show is made up of Pre-Perry songs that they're not even aware of.
Good concept for hard core fans, but a hard sell for the ticket buyers.
I don't understand. Most of the fans that bought these tickets KNOW about the Pre-Perry and the 3 Pre-Cain albums. That's why those tickets sold out in 5 minutes. Heck, I came into Journey (with Steve Perry) fandom late and even Iknow about and actually bought all 3 of them. Do I like them more than Infinity, Departure and Evolution? No. But are they good? Yeah, very good.
tater1977 wrote:NEAL SCHON MUSIC @NealSchonMusic
https://twitter.com/NealSchonMusic/stat ... 5172000770
The Independent SF tomorrow night. C U there
- if you enlarge the photo and flip it around, you can see a partial setlist.
scarab wrote:very cool, looks like this is leaning to the first 3 albums w/o Perry, only Perry song I saw until it blurred was Walks like a lady (and maybe Majestic)
Now they said there would be "special guests" and Neal even said they would do WLAL specifically at the RR HOF cause he knew Perry could still sing it. hmmm.....
The_Noble_Cause wrote:scarab wrote:very cool, looks like this is leaning to the first 3 albums w/o Perry, only Perry song I saw until it blurred was Walks like a lady (and maybe Majestic)
Now they said there would be "special guests" and Neal even said they would do WLAL specifically at the RR HOF cause he knew Perry could still sing it. hmmm.....
I think I see "Wheel in the Sky" and "Lights" on there too.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Not sure why he would have Separate Ways on there. Deeno on Twitter says they are filming a DVD.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Playing Cain-era stuff like SW is a big F-U to Cain. I love it.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 78 guests