Moderator: Andrew
Monker wrote:The first time I listened to "With All Due Respect", I liked. It this nice rock song, nice cool rhythm, nice guitar riffs, etc. I think the beginning is kinda stupid with that yadda yadda woof woof crap...but the rest was pretty good.
But, honestly, it just doesn't stick with me. It's not something I really care to go back and listen to. There is one article that compares it to Don Henley's "Dirty Laundry"...and it's a good comparison since they both are critiquing news media. But, "Dirty Laundry" doesn't just critique the news, it also asks people why they are watching this crap? Is it because it's being delivered by a cute blonde? Is it because you love the celebrity gossip? Do you like the drama of death and grieving? All Dennis is saying is the news media is a bunch of assholes. And, that's about it.
So, watching/listening is basically repeating, over and over again, the news media are assholes. So, it becomes "meh." very quick to me. Then I watch the video and the people in the chorus seem to be looking as much like assholes as the news media they are insulting. Then Dennis is being himself and acting all camping and dramatic...and that doesn't help much. The video has become something I really don't care to watch more than a couple times.
I know it's supposed to be all jovial, and fun, and almost a tongue in cheek joke. But, for me, it stops being that way after a couple times. Then it becomes a bunch of people calling another group of people assholes...and it's no longer fun.
Dennis said in one of those interviews that it is kind of an extension of a lyric in "Borrowed Time". But, "Borrowed Time" had more depth to it, a bit of a story - in a way.
"Turn Off CNN" is also comparable...but it is also a much better song with more depth, and likable.
yogi wrote:With All Due Respect, I TOTALLY disagree with both of you, on ALL of your points.
The actual news is just suppose to report the news. No slant, just report the facts and leave it at that. None of them do that. They are suppose to be impartial. Like umpires & referees. All they should be doing is calling balls & strikes.
Now since none of the media outlets are that way & they are all about spinning a story no one knows what to believe. It pits us against each other & it’s killing our country.
... ‘their hiding this behind their backs, their partisan hacks’
No truer line has ever been sung!
yogi wrote:It’s reached a far far far different level today and I know you are smart enough to realize that.
CNN & MSNBC are be far the biggest support group the Democratic Party has going for it. Add to this the major print media is probably @ a minimum 75% all in for the Dems.
On the other side you have Fox slanting every story possible toward the right.
This is all a far cry from the bubble headed bleach blond ( coming on @ 5) trying to sell her looks for viewers .
The media today wants to be the ones responsible for the election wins & losses for their team. They are doing it all for ratings & to please their very politically motivated bosses at the top.
Nothing like this, to this degree has ever happened before. Not even close!
yogi wrote:Wrong.
Nothing compares to how it is now with the internet & the 24 hr by the minute ‘news’ cycle which for the most part isn’t news but nothing more than partisan spin to a news story. Politicians, big & small business, unions etc.... always have and always will have agendas. The media should never. They are just suppose to deliver the news That’s it. What they are doing now is trying to decide who wins elections.
It’s criminal on BOTH sides & It’s never been like this, EVER!
yogi wrote:It’s an excellent, hard rocking with heavy guitars & great drum work catchy as hell song. The song has meaningful lyrics that are sung to perfection and it comes from an even better album.
Monker wrote:The first time I listened to "With All Due Respect", I liked. It this nice rock song, nice cool rhythm, nice guitar riffs, etc. I think the beginning is kinda stupid with that yadda yadda woof woof crap...but the rest was pretty good.
But, honestly, it just doesn't stick with me. It's not something I really care to go back and listen to. There is one article that compares it to Don Henley's "Dirty Laundry"...and it's a good comparison since they both are critiquing news media. But, "Dirty Laundry" doesn't just critique the news, it also asks people why they are watching this crap? Is it because it's being delivered by a cute blonde? Is it because you love the celebrity gossip? Do you like the drama of death and grieving? All Dennis is saying is the news media is a bunch of assholes. And, that's about it.
So, watching/listening is basically repeating, over and over again, the news media are assholes. So, it becomes "meh." very quick to me. Then I watch the video and the people in the chorus seem to be looking as much like assholes as the news media they are insulting. Then Dennis is being himself and acting all camping and dramatic...and that doesn't help much. The video has become something I really don't care to watch more than a couple times.
I know it's supposed to be all jovial, and fun, and almost a tongue in cheek joke. But, for me, it stops being that way after a couple times. Then it becomes a bunch of people calling another group of people assholes...and it's no longer fun.
Dennis said in one of those interviews that it is kind of an extension of a lyric in "Borrowed Time". But, "Borrowed Time" had more depth to it, a bit of a story - in a way.
"Turn Off CNN" is also comparable...but it is also a much better song with more depth, and likable.
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:"Dirty Laundry" is great but it’s different than Respect. But this would be for the nuanced thinker. Not a dupe who’s only purpose in life is to mindlessly troll.
"Dirty Laundry" focuses on celebrity tv gossip and character assassination, coupled with the idea of “if it bleeds it leads”. Sensationalism to get viewers is the similarity but it ends there.
Henley wrote the mostly inward looking lyric because he hard been vilified by the local LA news stations during the time he was accused of having underage girls at his home and giving them drugs. He was fined $2500 and put on probation. Today his career would be over.
“Respect” is so much more. The well being of our country hangs in the balance as news becomes entertainment looking to divide us as Dennis says using fear to sell bear.
So called news organizations hiding their partisan ways while cheering on the extremes to exacerbate our differences. This is very very different than Laundry. Even the title Dirty Laundry tells you it’s different.
The raves everywhere over Respect and it’s message has been a landslide of agreement in its premise and its cathartic chorus.
The press that song is getting is validation of Dennis once again giving voice to what’s important.
.......Not we’re going to Mars tra la. Now let’s wait for three run on posts as el dupe’ proves his ignorance unable to tell the differences in these two great songs.
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:Monker,
Years ago this was a fun forum to visit. It's sad to see that so many people left because of you, mainly you. Most were Classic Styx fans, mostly pro-Dennis but still didn't bash Current Styx like you do to Dennis. I'm not including Toph and Froy, just the others. I recently found out that a person was banned a few years ago in an argument with you. There's at least 9 people that I'm still in contact with that were on here but left.
This is how I feel about you when I saw this video.
THE BATHWATER DRINKERS LEGAL TEAM
EL DUPE’ AND THE MONKERS
https://youtu.be/74HGm_oEYxw
gr8dane wrote:SuiteMadameBlue wrote:Monker,
Years ago this was a fun forum to visit. It's sad to see that so many people left because of you, mainly you. Most were Classic Styx fans, mostly pro-Dennis but still didn't bash Current Styx like you do to Dennis. I'm not including Toph and Froy, just the others. I recently found out that a person was banned a few years ago in an argument with you. There's at least 9 people that I'm still in contact with that were on here but left.
This is how I feel about you when I saw this video.
THE BATHWATER DRINKERS LEGAL TEAM
EL DUPE’ AND THE MONKERS
https://youtu.be/74HGm_oEYxw
This forum is still lots of fun.
Why are you not including froy and toph ? Convenience ? Or because people left here, because of them ? LOL
yogi wrote:With All Due Respect we disagree.
With all this said 'With All Due Respect' is probably my 6th favorite song off of 26 East.
1. A KINGDOM ABLAZE
2. Run For The Roses
3. You My Love
4. Damn That Dream
5. To The Good Old Days
6. With All Due Respect
7. East of Midnight
8. Unbroken
9.The Promise of This Land
Still this is a song that needs to be out there RIGHT NOW.
The entire album is ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE
Monker wrote:SuiteMadameBlue wrote:"Dirty Laundry" is great but it’s different than Respect. But this would be for the nuanced thinker. Not a dupe who’s only purpose in life is to mindlessly troll.
Well, if I'm trolling, you just bit the bait. Who's more foolish, the fool or the fool that follows him?
Oh look the Pied Piper admits he’s a troll."Dirty Laundry" focuses on celebrity tv gossip and character assassination, coupled with the idea of “if it bleeds it leads”. Sensationalism to get viewers is the similarity but it ends there.
And, "With All Due Respect" is about the sensations of hearing someone call the news media assholes.
When assholes hear that word they can’t hear anything else. Not even great timely insightful lyrics.Henley wrote the mostly inward looking lyric because he hard been vilified by the local LA news stations during the time he was accused of having underage girls at his home and giving them drugs. He was fined $2500 and put on probation. Today his career would be over.
And, this has nothing to do with anything.
You brought up the Henley comparison and you we’re dead wrong. Attention class everyone study Michael Crichton. Even though Dennis said these things in 1979 not 1992. I missed it when you praised Dennis’s lyrics, you didn’t like Cornerstone.“Respect” is so much more. The well being of our country hangs in the balance as news becomes entertainment looking to divide us as Dennis says using fear to sell bear.
I assume you mean "beer". And, explain how the news media is selling beer.So called news organizations hiding their partisan ways while cheering on the extremes to exacerbate our differences. This is very very different than Laundry. Even the title Dirty Laundry tells you it’s different.
I said they were both critiquing the news media. I didn't say they were doing exactly the same thing.
Basically, all Dennis did was call the news media assholes. That's it. All the other lyrics set up the chorus to call them assholes. There is no deep meaning here at all.
No you said Henleys was more important and will last longer and “Kick em when there up kick em when there down” over and over. You’re still El Monker the dupe.The raves everywhere over Respect and it’s message has been a landslide of agreement in its premise and its cathartic chorus.
And, my opinion is the song is repetitive, and uses shock drama to get a reaction....and it bored me after a couple listens.The press that song is getting is validation of Dennis once again giving voice to what’s important.
I see. So, you think this is going to be a hit single?
Hint: I don't.
Probably not considering the current state of rock music on radio. It’s only been out 6 days and if Dirty Laundry were released to day it wouldn’t be either. Dennis wrote a song about technology in 1982 and it’s in the culture. Apples to apples........Not we’re going to Mars tra la. Now let’s wait for three run on posts as el dupe’ proves his ignorance unable to tell the differences in these two great songs.
I don't know if you are talking about "The Mission" or "Dirty Laundry". However, "With All Due Respect" has not achieved greatness. 40yrs from now, I think it will have been forgotten...not a classic like "Dirty Laundry". IMO, it will be more like "Turn Off CNN" and be forgotten in less than 10yrs.
Of course you do. And no rock records recorded these day will either.
Monker wrote:yogi wrote:With All Due Respect, I TOTALLY disagree with both of you, on ALL of your points.
The actual news is just suppose to report the news. No slant, just report the facts and leave it at that. None of them do that. They are suppose to be impartial. Like umpires & referees. All they should be doing is calling balls & strikes.
Now since none of the media outlets are that way & they are all about spinning a story no one knows what to believe. It pits us against each other & it’s killing our country.
... ‘their hiding this behind their backs, their partisan hacks’
No truer line has ever been sung!
I realize this. But, you do realize "Dirty Laundry" was released nearly 40yrs ago, correct? This is a critique that has been said over and over and over again for my entire adult life. Even Dennis himself has said this is a continuation from the line in "Borrowed Tome", and he wrote about it last time with "Turn Off CNN". It's not like the line you quoted is some revolutionary new critique.
Michael Crichton gave two speeches on this subject; "Mediasaurus" is seen as a bit of a famous one. And, "Why Speculate?" which changed the way I look at pundits on the news (or on these forums) and their predictions of the future. "Mediasaurus" was written nearly 30yrs ago. ""Why Speculate?" was written nearly 20yrs ago....but both could apply to today.
(Mediasaurus) https://www.wired.com/1993/04/mediasaurus/
(Why Speculate) - http://www.crichton-official.com/speech ... ulate.html
Both of the above are good reads, if you are interested in the subject.
My point isn't whether or not the news media is worthy of critique. My point is that this is less than critique and more just repeatedly calling them assholes. It's cheap, easy, no brains critique. It's like Beavis or Butthead saying something 'sucks'. There is no substance to it. It reminds me of a trend in movies and TV that I call "shock drama". It's like a character walking up to a new born baby,...and then breaking its neck and killing it. It is an easy way to get a reaction, but it is hollow, empty, doesn't move anything forward, and the emotional reaction doesn't last.
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:This is how I feel about you when I saw this video.
THE BATHWATER DRINKERS LEGAL TEAM
EL DUPE’ AND THE MONKERS
https://youtu.be/74HGm_oEYxw
“Breaking a new born baby’s neck and killing it” who thinks like this, only evil.
People on this site and Andrew take heed of who this troll is. Flag him and kick off this site he’s a menace. This is his idea of critiquing a song.
LtVanish wrote:Please stop even comparing DDY to Don Henley. Don Henley is just an awful POS, the Eagles Documentary proves that point end of story. I bet Monker likes the song "All She Wants to Do is Dance" that's a real winner of a song.
gr8dane wrote:SuiteMadameBlue wrote:Monker,
Years ago this was a fun forum to visit. It's sad to see that so many people left because of you, mainly you. Most were Classic Styx fans, mostly pro-Dennis but still didn't bash Current Styx like you do to Dennis. I'm not including Toph and Froy, just the others. I recently found out that a person was banned a few years ago in an argument with you. There's at least 9 people that I'm still in contact with that were on here but left.
This is how I feel about you when I saw this video.
THE BATHWATER DRINKERS LEGAL TEAM
EL DUPE’ AND THE MONKERS
https://youtu.be/74HGm_oEYxw
This forum is still lots of fun.
Why are you not including froy and toph ? Convenience ? Or because people left here, because of them ? LOL
yogi wrote:There’s no better word to describe the majority of the media pundits these days. They are the ones selling the shock factor thats dividing our country.
Calling them ( the media) cockroaches just wouldn’t of worked with the pounding drums and blazing guitar work in this song.
“ With All Due Respect you are a cockroach”. With All Due Respect you make me sick, With All Due Respect....
Maybe this could be( substituting cockroach for asshole)the Tony Montana version as the media tries their damndest to turn us into Cuba. But does Cuba even allow rock music?? Oh Shit we are now back to Kilroy
Monker wrote:Just a note about froyline and Toph...they did not leave the forum on their own....Andrew kicked them off.
Andrew wrote:Monker wrote:Just a note about froyline and Toph...they did not leave the forum on their own....Andrew kicked them off.
And like all buffoons removed from this board, I hadn't thought of any of them since banning.
Re: others leaving - I haven't received one email or PM. Who left and why exactly?
But Monker, I think the baby killing reference is a bit graphic/too much....can you remove that quote?
yogi wrote:In regards of anything DDY 'With All Due Respect' Monkier you are a partisan hack
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests