STYX VS JOURNEY - The Singles

[yogi]

Lets compare you pick the winners:

Lights vs Lights
Kiss Your Ass Goodbye vs Remember Me
Queen Of Spades vs Escape
Castle Walls vs Mother Father
Born For Adventure/Suite Madame Blue vs Feeling That Way/Anytime
Renegade vs Seperate Ways
Waiting For Our Time vs Message Of Love
Babe vs Open Arms
Best Of Times vs Faithfully
Show Me The Way vs When You Love A Woman
Come Sail Away vs Dont Stop Believein
Crystal Ball vs Only The Young
Blue Collar Man vs Anyway You Want It
Lady vs Lovin Touchin Squeezin
Lorelei vs Wheel In The Sky
Dont Let It End vs Whos Crying Now
Fooling Yourself vs Girl Cant Help It
One With Everything vs Higher Place
Too Much Time On My Hands vs Ask The Lonely
Mr. Roboto vs Be Good To Yourself

Tiebreaker:

Hip Hop vs Baby I'm A Leavin You

[sadie65]

Lets compare you pick the winners:

Lights vs Lights
Kiss Your Ass Goodbye vs Remember Me
Queen Of Spades vs Escape
Castle Walls vs Mother Father
Born For Adventure/Suite Madame Blue vs Feeling That Way/Anytime
Renegade vs Seperate Ways
Waiting For Our Time vs Message Of Love
Babe vs Open Arms
Best Of Times vs Faithfully
Show Me The Way vs When You Love A Woman
Come Sail Away vs Dont Stop Believein
Crystal Ball vs Only The Young
Blue Collar Man vs Anyway You Want It
Lady vs Lovin Touchin Squeezin
Lorelei vs Wheel In The Sky
Dont Let It End vs Whos Crying Now
Fooling Yourself vs Girl Cant Help It
One With Everything vs Higher Place
Too Much Time On My Hands vs Ask The Lonely
Mr. Roboto vs Be Good To Yourself

Tiebreaker:

Hip Hop vs Baby I'm A Leavin You

1. Lights
2. Remember me
3. Queen of Spades
4. Castle Walls
5. BFA/SMB
6. Message of Love
7. Open Arms
8. Best of Times
9. Show Me the Way
10. Tie
11. Crystal Ball
12. Any Way You Want It
13. Lady...but it was a tough call
14. Wheel in the Sky
15. Don't Let it End
16. Foolin Yourself
17. One With Everything
18. TMTOMH
19. Mr. Roboto


Tie Break:
Hip-Hop

Sadie

[Monker]

Lights - Journey
Kiss Your Ass Goodbye
Escape
Castle Walls vs Mother Father - a tie, I guess.
Feeling That Way/Anytime
Renegade vs Seperate Ways - tie
Waiting For Our Time
Open Arms
Best Of Times
When You Love A Woman
Come Sail Away vs Dont Stop Believein - tie
Crystal Ball
Blue Collar Man vs Anyway You Want It - tie
Lady
Wheel In The Sky
Dont Let It End vs Whos Crying Now - tie
Fooling Yourself

One With Everything vs Higher Place - I would think it should be "Waiting for Our Time" since they would have both been first singles. I'll vote for Higher Place in either case.

Too Much Time On My Hands
Be Good To Yourself

Hip Hop vs Baby I'm A Leavin You - Err, yeah, right. Neither. You may as well compare Plexiglass Toilet vs. Backtalk or "Music Time" vs. "Only Solutions". Or, Burshwah Pig vs "Dead or Alive".

[ek88]

Lights (Styx)
Kiss Your Ass Goodbye
Escape
Castle Walls
Born For Adventure/Suite Madame Blue
Renegade
Waiting For Our Time
Open Arms
Best Of Times
When You Love A Woman
Come Sail Away
Crystal Ball vs Only The Young (tie)
Blue Collar Man
Lady
Wheel In The Sky
Whos Crying Now
Fooling Yourself
One With Everything
Ask The Lonely
Be Good To Yourself

Baby I'm A Leavin You (don't think I've heard this one but anything's got to be better than Hip-Hop)

[yogi]

I actually disagree with you on Baby I'm A Leavin You. Hip Hop is AWEFUL, I mean BRUTAL AWEFUL. Baby I'm A Leavin You may be the WORST song I have EVER heard. Worse than Hip Hop its that bad!

[piecesofeight]

Lets compare you pick the winners:

Lights vs Lights-LIGHTS
Kiss Your Ass Goodbye vs Remember Me-REMEMBER ME
Queen Of Spades vs Escape-ESCAPE
Castle Walls vs Mother Father-CASTLE WALLS
Born For Adventure/Suite Madame Blue vs Feeling That Way/Anytime-F.A.
Renegade vs Seperate Ways-SEPERATE WAYS
Waiting For Our Time vs Message Of Love-MESSAGE OF LOVE
Babe vs Open Arms-OPEN ARMS
Best Of Times vs Faithfully-FAITHFULLY
Show Me The Way vs When You Love A Woman-WHEN YOU LOVE A WOMA
Come Sail Away vs Dont Stop Believein-TIE
Crystal Ball vs Only The Young-ONLY THE YOUNG
Blue Collar Man vs Anyway You Want It-ANY WAY YOU WANT IT
Lady vs Lovin Touchin Squeezin-LADY
Lorelei vs Wheel In The Sky-LORELEI
Dont Let It End vs Whos Crying Now-D.L.I.E.
Fooling Yourself vs Girl Cant Help It-FOOLING YOURSELF
One With Everything vs Higher Place-HIGHER PLACE
Too Much Time On My Hands vs Ask The Lonely-ASK THE LONELY
Mr. Roboto vs Be Good To Yourself-BE GOOD TO YOURSELF

Tiebreaker:

Hip Hop vs Baby I'm A Leavin You

Sorry, got lazy today. The caps in Yogi's quoate are my answers.

[Abitaman]

Lights (JRNY)
Remember Me
Queen of Spades
Castle Walls
Suite Madame Blue
Renegade
Message of Love
Open Arms
Best of Times
Show ME the Way
Come Sail Away
Cyrstal BAll
Blue Collar Man
Lady
Wheel in the Sky
Who's Crying Now
Fooling Yourself
One with Everything
Ask the Lonely
Mr Roboto
Hip Hop-ERIC

[bugsymalone]

Lights
Remember Me
Queen Of Spades
Castle Walls
Born For Adventure/Suite Madame Blue
Seperate Ways
Message Of Love
Open Arms
Best of Times AND Faithfully (tie)
Show Me The Way
Come Sail Away
Only the Young
Anyway You Want It
Lady
Lorelei
Whos Crying Now
Fooling Yourself AND Girl Can't Help It (tie)
Higher Place
Ask The Lonely
Mr. Roboto

Hip Hop (OH YEAH!!)

Bugsy

[SuiteMadameBlue]

I'll play, here are my winners

Lights - Styx
Kiss Your Ass Goodbye
Queen Of Spades
Castle Walls
Born For Adventure/Suite Madame Blue
Seperate Ways
Message Of Love
Open Arms (sorry, I have a little history with this song)
Best Of Times
Show Me The Way
Come Sail Away
Crystal Ball
Anyway You Want It
Lady
Lorelei
Dont Let It End
Girl Cant Help It
Higher Place
Ask The Lonely
Mr. Roboto

Tiebreaker:

Hip Hop - I don't think I heard the Journey song

[ek88]

Now, yogi, if you were an overachiever, you would tally the results up for us

[sadie65]

Now, yogi, if you were an overachiever, you would tally the results up for us

being the sick and twisted individual I am, I tallied them.

So far:

Lights (4) vs. Lights (5)
KYAG (2)vs. Remember Me (4)
QOS (5) vs Escape (3)
CW (7) vs Mother Father (1)
BFA/SMB (5) vs FTW/Anytime (2)
Renegade (4) vs SW (5)
WFOT (3) vs MOL (4)
Babe (0) vs Open Arms (7)
BOT (5) vs Faithfully (2)
SMTW (4) vs WYLAW (3)
CSA (7) vs DSB (3)
CB (5) vs OTL (3)
BCM (3) vs AYWI (5)
Lady (7) vs LTS (0)
Lorelei (3) vs WITS (4)
DLIE (4) vs WCN (4)
FY (6) vs GCHI (2)
OWE (4) vs Higher Place (3)
TMTOMH (2) vs ATL (5)
Mr. Roboto (4) vs BGTY (3)

Hip-hop (4) vs Baby I'm a Leavin You (1)

Sadie

[bugsymalone]

BTW, Sadie. My "Lights" vote was for Styx. But you knew that anyway, no?

Bugsy

[ek88]

Sheesh, we seem to have a bit of a Journey undercurrent here, based on the results. I'm a little surprised the results aren't more decisively in favor of Styx here at a Styx message board. Interesting.

[Abitaman]

JUst because Styx is the main focus here, they may not rule on every single thing. Journey is an awesome group-ERIC

[DeeJaySTYX]

1( Lights vs Lights (tie)
2( Kiss Your Ass Goodbye
3( Queen Of Spades
4( Castle Walls
5( B.F.A./S.M.B
6( Renegade
7( Waiting For Our Time
8( Babe vs Open Arms (tie)
9( Best Of Times vs Faithfully (tie)
10( Show Me The Way vs When You Love A Woman (tie)
11( Come Sail Away
12( Crystal Ball
13( Any Way You Want It
14( Lady vs Lovin Touchin Squeezin (tie)
15( Lorelei vs Wheel In The Sky (tie)
16( Don't Let It End
17( Fooling Yourself
18( One With Everything
19( Too Much Time On My Hands
20( Be Good To Yourself

Tie Breaker

Hip Hop Vs Baby I'm Leaving You (Niether)


DeeJay.....

[yogi]

Before I pick my winners I should say I compared the songs I like against other songs I like. The songs I dislike I compared against songs I dislike. My winners are:

1. Lights- Journey- both songs OK
2. KYAG vs Remember Me - Push - GREAT Songs
3. Escape - great songs
4. Castle Walls vs Mother/Father- PUSH - great songs
5. Born For Adventure/Suite Madame - My favorite group of songs by both
6. Renegade - good songs
7. Waiting For Our Time vs Message Of Love - PUSH - both decent
8. Babe vs Open Arms - PUSH - dont really like either
9. Best Of Times - Really like these two ballads
10. Show Me The Way- both excellent songs
11. Come Sail Away- both excellent
12. Crystal Ball - both decent
13. Blue Collar Man- good song, JY's mimed version is best
14. Lovin Touchin Squeezin - both great songs
15. Wheel In The Sky- decent song
16. Who's Crying Now - decent ballad
17. Girl cant Help It - decent song
18. One with Everything - very good song
19. Ask the Lonely - good song
20. Mr Roboto vs Be Good - PUSH - dont like either

tie breaker: Hip Hop - two of the worst songs EVER