Moderator: Andrew
cittadeeno23 wrote:I really wish I had not watched that Castle Walls clip.
pinkfloyd1973 wrote:cittadeeno23 wrote:I really wish I had not watched that Castle Walls clip.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLJZAZC6oEc&feature=related
Everett wrote:pinkfloyd1973 wrote:cittadeeno23 wrote:I really wish I had not watched that Castle Walls clip.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLJZAZC6oEc&feature=related
pinkfloyd1973 wrote:Everett wrote:pinkfloyd1973 wrote:cittadeeno23 wrote:I really wish I had not watched that Castle Walls clip.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLJZAZC6oEc&feature=related
You gotta admit that the clip with Larry singing "Castle Walls" was pretty painful![]()
Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
purpleplanet10 wrote:Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
i really like it.. its the first time i am hearing some of these songs.. i wanna get the CD's but these live versions kick ass!!
purpleplanet10 wrote:Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
i really like it.. its the first time i am hearing some of these songs.. i wanna get the CD's but these live versions kick ass!!
Babyblue wrote:purpleplanet10 wrote:Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
i really like it.. its the first time i am hearing some of these songs.. i wanna get the CD's but these live versions kick ass!!
Thank You!!!!!! I thought he was great.But hey i am pro Larry anyway.
![]()
Babyblue wrote:
Sweet!
Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
brywool wrote:Babyblue wrote:
Sweet!
Always thought GWH was one of JY's best tunes. Loved the beginning of that on the original Pieces of 8 Tour- Front row, yellow Styx shirt. Great tour. I remember being disappointed that Dennis kind of just spoke the intro half-assed compared to how he did it on the studio version which was very animated and cool. Kind of like he does the yell in Renegade (whimpy)- Dennis, put some balls into it like the album. Larry does that bit better than Dennis did live for sure.
I'd like to say this one sounds good cuz it's a favorite, but JY's not hitting the notes AT ALL and is choosing to scream some parts out. You can hear him struggle with them in a BIG way. In fact, between this song and the Superstars clip that was posted last week, I've not heard him struggle this much until now, and I've listened to him since 77. It's surprising because he's been singing pretty much non-stop for forever now, so you think he'd be up to it. Also, JY bungs up the guitar solo too. He totally goes out of key, which is something I've also never heard him do. Dang... Come on JY... I have faith!
HOLY CRAP! Ricky's on a Ric now! YES. LOVE LOVE LOVE that bass!
This has got to be THE worst live Styx clip I've heard ever. Tommy should ghost him on the vocal to help him out. I think that JY can do it, but because it's something he hasn't done in mega years, his muscle memory has to kind of relearn where to go for the high notes on this one. JY, blow less air, point the sound to just below your eyebrows and you'll hit those notes. Don't scream it dude.
brywool wrote:Babyblue wrote:
Sweet!
Always thought GWH was one of JY's best tunes. Loved the beginning of that on the original Pieces of 8 Tour- Front row, yellow Styx shirt. Great tour. I remember being disappointed that Dennis kind of just spoke the intro half-assed compared to how he did it on the studio version which was very animated and cool. Kind of like he does the yell in Renegade (whimpy)- Dennis, put some balls into it like the album. Larry does that bit better than Dennis did live for sure.
I'd like to say this one sounds good cuz it's a favorite, but JY's not hitting the notes AT ALL and is choosing to scream some parts out. You can hear him struggle with them in a BIG way. In fact, between this song and the Superstars clip that was posted last week, I've not heard him struggle this much until now, and I've listened to him since 77. It's surprising because he's been singing pretty much non-stop for forever now, so you think he'd be up to it. Also, JY bungs up the guitar solo too. He totally goes out of key, which is something I've also never heard him do. Dang... Come on JY... I have faith!
HOLY CRAP! Ricky's on a Ric now! YES. LOVE LOVE LOVE that bass!
This has got to be THE worst live Styx clip I've heard ever. Tommy should ghost him on the vocal to help him out. I think that JY can do it, but because it's something he hasn't done in mega years, his muscle memory has to kind of relearn where to go for the high notes on this one. JY, blow less air, point the sound to just below your eyebrows and you'll hit those notes. Don't scream it dude.
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:Babyblue wrote:purpleplanet10 wrote:Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
i really like it.. its the first time i am hearing some of these songs.. i wanna get the CD's but these live versions kick ass!!
Thank You!!!!!! I thought he was great.But hey i am pro Larry anyway.
![]()
Seriously? You're Pro Larry?
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
brywool wrote: point the sound to just below your eyebrows and you'll hit those notes.
brywool wrote:Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
Regarding emotion... kinda hard to find emotion with lyrics about Camelot! Not that there's a lot to relate to there for anyone actually. Not sure why Gowan's getting dogged on this one. He sounds fine to me. A little more subdued than Dennis' over annunciation of everything like he used to, but it's a decent vocal. Dennis sang it great originally and Gowan isn't Dennis, so, it's gonna be different. The keyboard sounds... come on, you can't judge that by Youtube. Pitch, playing, and intensity you can, but they sound great here. Compare them to Todd's drums. Now imagine both at full volume. It'd be very cool. Again, JY seems to be off a bit in his playing and also Tommy misses a guitar chord coming back into the last chorus.
brywool wrote:Babyblue wrote:
Sweet!
I'd like to say this one sounds good cuz it's a favorite, but JY's not hitting the notes AT ALL and is choosing to scream some parts out. You can hear him struggle with them in a BIG way.
brywool wrote:Boomchild wrote:
Weak. No emotion to the performance. Keyboard solo is weak compared to how DDY does it.
Regarding emotion... kinda hard to find emotion with lyrics about Camelot! Not that there's a lot to relate to there for anyone actually. Not sure why Gowan's getting dogged on this one. He sounds fine to me. A little more subdued than Dennis' over annunciation of everything like he used to, but it's a decent vocal. Dennis sang it great originally and Gowan isn't Dennis, so, it's gonna be different. The keyboard sounds... come on, you can't judge that by Youtube. Pitch, playing, and intensity you can, but they sound great here. Compare them to Todd's drums. Now imagine both at full volume. It'd be very cool. Again, JY seems to be off a bit in his playing and also Tommy misses a guitar chord coming back into the last chorus.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests